Onpode
Cover art for Amy Poehler and Mike Schur reunite for Dig—a show that might not exist if Parks faced today's streaming economics

Amy Poehler and Mike Schur reunite for Dig—a show that might not exist if Parks faced today's streaming economics

November 20, 2026 · 9 min

Hope Sterling & Finn Brooks

hi — okay you know how sometimes a show gets announced and you're like, sure, fine, whatever, and then you actually look at it and it's like — wait, Hugh Laurie is the eccentric professor who won't retire? on a Peacock comedy? with Amy Poehler playing an archaeologist? that's Dig. that's the whole thing. that…

Dig is a 10-episode comedy series premiering on Peacock on November 23, 2026, reuniting Amy Poehler and Mike Schur — the creative team behind Parks and Recreation — along with co-creator J.J. Philbin.

0:008:56
Get the next episode on lost, scrapped, unaired sitcoms we will NEVER get to see →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on lost, scrapped, unaired sitcoms we will NEVER get to see →

About this episode

Dig is a 10-episode comedy series premiering on Peacock on November 23, 2026, reuniting Amy Poehler and Mike Schur — the creative team behind Parks and Recreation — along with co-creator J.J. Philbin.

Grounded in 6 sources
From a pit in Pawnee to one in Greece: Amy Poehler and Mike Schur reunite for ‘Dig’ - Los Angeles Times ↗ · latimes.com
Amy Poehler to reunite with 'Parks and Recreation' creator on new ... ↗ · 98online.com
Dig reunites Amy Poehler and Mike Schur for a show with Parks And Rec’s charm and heart, if not its laughs - A.V. Club ↗ · avclub.com
https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-reviews/dig-review-amy-poehler-mike-schur-hugh-laurie-peacock-1236758949/ ↗ · hollywoodreporter.com
'Dig' Comedy From Amy Poehler & Mike Schur Picked Up To Series ... ↗ · imdb.com
Peacock’s ‘DIG’: Inside Amy Poehler and Michael Schur’s New Comedy | NBCUNIVERSAL MEDIA ↗ · nbcuniversal.com
Read transcript

Hope Sterling: hi — okay you know how sometimes a show gets announced and you're like, sure, fine, whatever, and then you actually look at it and it's like — wait, Hugh Laurie is the eccentric professor who won't retire? on a Peacock comedy? with Amy Poehler playing an archaeologist?

Finn Brooks: that's Dig. that's the whole thing.

Hope Sterling: that is Dig! ten episodes, November 23rd, Amy plays Elise DeBellnick who's basically been waiting her whole career to take over this excavation site in Greece and Mike Schur and J.J. Philbin co-created it with her and I — I mean this is a real television event, like —

Finn Brooks: and reviews dropped. and they are not aligned.

Hope Sterling: not even a little! A.V. Club is basically like, it has Parks and Rec's heart and charm, just — not the laughs. which, okay. but then Polygon is over here saying the story isn't particularly interesting and questioning whether Elise even works as a protagonist to follow —

Finn Brooks: wait, Elise is unlikable? that's the Polygon read? because that feels like a much more serious problem than "not enough laughs" —

Hope Sterling: right?! like those are two completely different shows they're describing. one is a gentle charmer and one is a show with a protagonist problem.

Finn Brooks: and that split is going to be the whole conversation about Dig before anyone's even finished episode three.

Hope Sterling: but wait — the review split isn't even the actual story here, is it?

Finn Brooks: no! Dig being good isn't even the question — it's how it got made at all. like, Peacock just... handed them ten episodes. no pilot, no ratings test, nothing. Amy and Mike walked in with their names and walked out with the keys.

Hope Sterling: versus Parks and Rec, which like — that show was genuinely struggling early on? NBC kept it anyway and it became a thing.

Finn Brooks: exactly that — Parks had to earn survival under real pressure, and the pressure is kind of why it got weird and funny. Dig just skipped all of that. which is — I mean, is that good? I actually don't know. it might be both.

Hope Sterling: okay but the book it's based on? Kate Myers wrote it in 2023. I cannot get over that.

Finn Brooks: wait, 2023? so it literally just came out?

Hope Sterling: literally just came out! it's called Excavations, and it's not like — this isn't a beloved classic people spent decades begging to see adapted. Amy Poehler wanted it, and that was enough. the whole thing got fast-tracked on her wanting it.

Finn Brooks: so the core thing is — only people who already won get to skip the line. Poehler, Schur, J.J. Philbin — they're the ones who can walk into Peacock with brand new, unproven source material and get ten episodes no questions asked. anyone without that résumé? their pitch just sits there.

Hope Sterling: mmm, and that's the part that actually stings a little — not for Dig specifically, just like... the model.

Finn Brooks: But the model thing is actually the WRONG starting point, because — hang on — the take that's everywhere right now, the one that's already baked into every review, is 'spiritual successor to Parks and Rec,' and I think that framing is doing active damage to this show before anyone's even watched it.

Hope Sterling: oh my gosh, YES — name it, because I've been screaming about this internally.

Finn Brooks: Elise DeBellnick is a veteran archaeologist in Greece waiting for Hugh Laurie's character to retire. That is — structurally, emotionally, like, in every way — nothing like Leslie Knope. Leslie was an optimistic civic crusader in a small Indiana town who wanted to build a park. These are not the same woman.

Hope Sterling: and it's why the reviews are reading completely differently! Polygon calls Elise unlikable, the LA Times calls her highly competent and driven, and A.V. Club is like, oh she's got that work-hard Leslie energy — same character, three totally different people basically. which means reviewers are projecting Leslie onto her and then getting confused when she doesn't fit.

Finn Brooks: wait but isn't that just — okay I love this, BUT — isn't that just what happens when you put Amy Poehler in anything? like, is it the marketing's fault or is it just... her face?

Hope Sterling: no! no, because — okay, Kayvan Novak is in this. Kayvan Novak from What We Do in the Shadows, playing the mayor of this little Greek town who has a crush on Elise. and Fina Strazza plays this inexperienced farm girl who shows up as Neville's new assistant. that's not a Pawnee ensemble, that's not even close to the same show's DNA.

Finn Brooks: right right — Greece isn't Pawnee, Elise isn't Leslie, the whole setup is fundamentally different and the 'spiritual successor' label is just... nostalgia doing the marketing's job for free.

Hope Sterling: and people walk in expecting Leslie Knope energy and get something grounded and quieter and then they're like, 'why isn't this funnier?' — when actually that might just be the show! the frame is setting the wrong expectation and then getting credited as a review.

Finn Brooks: calling it a spiritual successor might genuinely be the single thing that hurts it most. and honestly — the part that makes all of this worse is coming, because the greenlight model that handed them ten episodes? it's built on proving yourself under a system that doesn't even exist anymore. we'll get there.

Hope Sterling: and that's the part that like — the system that made them worth betting on literally doesn't exist in the same form anymore. NBC kept Parks and Rec alive through rough early ratings under the broadcast model, and that pressure is why Amy and Mike became the people Peacock is now betting on. that whole pipeline is gone.

Finn Brooks: right — so the freedom they have now was earned inside a system that would not let Dig survive. if Dig were the first thing they ever made? ten episodes, no pilot, no famous names? it doesn't get made. a writer pitching the exact same show, same premise, same Greece excavation whodunit group-hang thing — sitting in a pile.

Hope Sterling: the Hollywood Reporter called it a 'group hang comedy complicated by a whodunit layer' — which, honestly? that pitch works. that's a real show. but only if Amy Poehler is attached.

Finn Brooks: and Peacock doesn't even — wait, this is the actual thing — Peacock doesn't need Dig to be great. they needed Amy Poehler's name in the press release. that's the whole transaction.

Hope Sterling: that's cold.

Finn Brooks: it is! and I mean — I don't think it's malicious, it's just what streaming math looks like now. a recognizable name moves subscribers, or at least press. the show being genuinely good is almost... secondary to that goal. which is a weird thing to sit with when the show might actually be charming.

Hope Sterling: okay but here's my 'wait, really?' on that — does that mean the pressure that shaped Parks and Rec, the actual fight to survive that made Mike Schur and Amy Poehler worth betting on in the first place, is just... absent from Dig? like the very thing Peacock is buying doesn't exist in this show's DNA?

Finn Brooks: that's — yeah, that's exactly the closed loop. they proved themselves under conditions that no longer exist, and now they're operating in conditions that can't produce the next them.

Hope Sterling: so watch for whoever the next Mike Schur is — because they're not getting ten episodes on Peacock. they're getting a 'we'll circle back.'

Finn Brooks: my detail is — Parks and Rec almost got canceled. like, real cancellation pressure, bad early ratings, the whole thing. and that fight is literally why Amy and Mike became the people Peacock is betting on now. Dig never had to do that. never even got close to that moment.

Hope Sterling: mine is Kate Myers. 2023! the book literally just came out and it's already a ten-episode Peacock series because Amy Poehler wanted it. that's — I mean, that's the whole story in one sentence.

Finn Brooks: if Dig had aired on broadcast in 2009, soft first season, questionable ratings — it either gets canceled or it gets weird and funny trying to survive. and we will never know which one.

Hope Sterling: that's the thing that's gonna sit with me after I watch it. like, is this the show, or is this the show before the show?

Finn Brooks: November 23rd. I'll bring snacks.