Onpode
Cover art for Experts warn that executing Christa Pike again after her failed attempt would push into unprecedented legal territory

Experts warn that executing Christa Pike again after her failed attempt would push into unprecedented legal territory

November 13, 2026 · 10 min

Eliza Ward & Brian Reed

Hey. Good to be here. Yeah, good to be here. Though — I mean, the story we're starting with today is not an easy one. No. So — September 30th. Tennessee attempted to execute Christa Pike by lethal injection. Two full doses of pentobarbital. The state's maximum allowable amount under protocol. And she survived. She…

On September 30, 2026, Tennessee carried out a failed execution of Christa Pike, 50, the only woman on Tennessee's death row, after two doses of pentobarbital administered during the lethal injection did not kill her. At least seven needles were used in attempts to establish IV access; execution team members had warned beforehand that some of Pike's veins may have "blown."

0:009:53
Get the next episode on christa pike →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on christa pike →

About this episode

On September 30, 2026, Tennessee carried out a failed execution of Christa Pike, 50, the only woman on Tennessee's death row, after two doses of pentobarbital administered during the lethal injection did not kill her. At least seven needles were used in attempts to establish IV access; execution team members had warned beforehand that some of Pike's veins may have "blown."

Grounded in 11 sources
Tennessee AG Jonathan Skrmetti moves to block Christa Pike lawyers from testing pentobarbital vials. ↗ · apnews.com
How other executions failed in the US before Christa Pike | AP News ↗ · apnews.com
Could Christa Pike face execution again and by what method? ↗ · bbc.com
Victims’ families lash out at Gavin Newsom after mass commutation of ‘monsters’ on death row in California - NBC News ↗ · nbcnews.com
IV team warned Christa Pike's vein might have 'blown' during failed execution, court filing says | PBS News ↗ · pbs.org
Supreme Court blocks Alabama nitrogen gas execution of double murderer ↗ · usatoday.com
Christa Pike's attorney describes botched execution, concerns about 'blown' veins in new court filing - ABC News ↗ · abcnews.com
Christa Pike unconscious and on ventilator in hospital after botched execution, attorneys say - ABC News ↗ · abcnews.com
State asks judge to stop Pike lawyers from testing leftover execution drug | Davidson County Herald ↗ · davidsoncountyherald.com
Christa Pike | Death Penalty Information Center ↗ · deathpenaltyinfo.org
Christa Pike - Wikipedia ↗ · en.wikipedia.org
Read transcript

Brian Reed: Hey. Good to be here.

Eliza Ward: Yeah, good to be here. Though — I mean, the story we're starting with today is not an easy one.

Brian Reed: No. So — September 30th. Tennessee attempted to execute Christa Pike by lethal injection. Two full doses of pentobarbital. The state's maximum allowable amount under protocol. And she survived.

Eliza Ward: She survived.

Brian Reed: They used at least seven needles trying to get IV access. At one point Pike was heard crying. She said her arm — and I'm reading from court filings here — 'feels like it's about to burst open.' And then she was hospitalized at Vanderbilt University Medical Center, unconscious, on a ventilator.

Eliza Ward: Wait — the same night this happened, the U.S. Supreme Court had already lifted the 6th Circuit stay. In a brief unsigned order. So the execution proceeded with full judicial blessing.

Brian Reed: Yeah. The 6th Circuit had paused it 2-1, to give itself time to actually consider her arguments — and the Supreme Court just — lifted it. That night.

Eliza Ward: So every legal door was open. And what happened in that chamber happened anyway. She was on a ventilator at Vanderbilt. By October 5th her lawyers believed she was brain dead — and then she regained consciousness October 6th, and was back in prison by October 10th. I don't — I mean, that timeline alone.

Brian Reed: And that timeline is where I want to push on the 'uncharted territory' framing — because Alan Miller and Kenneth Smith went through almost exactly this. Failed Alabama lethal injections in 2022. Same Eighth Amendment 'as applied' arguments. Courts called them plausible. And then both men were executed by nitrogen gas in 2024.

Eliza Ward: Right — but the part that doesn't fit is that the Supreme Court never actually resolved the constitutional question. Miller and Smith got executed before anyone had to answer it.

Brian Reed: So saying 'the Alabama cases show Pike will probably lose' — does that even hold? The courts didn't decide. They just... moved on.

Eliza Ward: That's the real gap. And — wait, actually I think the double-dose fact is what makes Pike's case materially different from Miller and Smith. Here's the intuition: think of it like a firing squad that fires every bullet it's allowed to fire — and misses. The state has discharged its legal weapon. The question is whether loading a new one is a second punishment or just finishing the first.

Brian Reed: That's the click.

Eliza Ward: Robert Dunham frames it as two separate questions — double jeopardy under the Fifth Amendment and cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth. The double-dose fact feeds both. Tennessee's position is the sentence hasn't been carried out. Pike's side says the state already delivered everything pharmacologically it's allowed to deliver.

Brian Reed: And Miller and Smith — I mean, their injections failed but it wasn't the full protocol twice. So the quantity actually matters to the legal argument, not just to how bad it was.

Eliza Ward: That's the distinction courts haven't had to test yet. Dunham's Fifth and Eighth Amendment framing might be the first time a case actually forces the answer — if Tennessee tries again.

Brian Reed: And that's the part we genuinely don't know. What does Tennessee actually do next?

Eliza Ward: And that's exactly where the Skrmetti move becomes — wait, hold on. Because there's a take circulating that the AG blocking independent testing of the vials is just routine evidence preservation. Protecting the state's chain of custody. I want to push back on that pretty hard.

Brian Reed: Routine how? A state that's confident its protocol worked doesn't block outside labs from confirming it.

Eliza Ward: That's the tell. Think about it like — okay, imagine a hospital pharmacist compounds a drug, the patient nearly dies, and then the hospital blocks any outside lab from testing whether the dose was correct. You don't do that if you think the dose was fine.

Brian Reed: And Pike's attorneys have already filed an emergency motion in Davidson County Chancery Court just to get the Tennessee Department of Correction to preserve the evidence at all. They're fighting to keep the vials from disappearing.

Eliza Ward: Right — and here's the internal contradiction that actually breaks the 'routine' framing. Bill Lee orders an independent investigation. Jonathan Skrmetti simultaneously blocks the most direct physical evidence from that investigation. Those two moves don't — I mean, how is Lee's review independent if the AG is deciding what it can test?

Brian Reed: And this isn't Tennessee's first vein problem in 2026. Tony Carruthers — May 2026 — his execution was halted because medical staff couldn't find a vein. That's two failed executions in one year. And now we learn before Pike's attempt, the IV team warned that some of her veins may have already blown. A needle came out bent at a 90-degree angle.

Eliza Ward: They were warned. Before they started.

Brian Reed: So the question isn't whether something went wrong in that chamber — it's whether the pentobarbital itself was part of what went wrong. And blocking independent testing of the vials is the one move that keeps that question permanently unanswered. That's not neutral. That's a choice about what gets known.

Eliza Ward: And the institutional read on all of this — Strada's resignation, the moratorium, what Jack Johnson said about January — that's actually fascinating. We'll get to that.

Brian Reed: Strada is the clearest signal we have. Commissioner of the Tennessee Department of Correction — resigned October 3rd. Three days after Pike's failed execution. That's not a scheduled departure. That's someone who saw what happened and decided he couldn't put his name on the next one.

Eliza Ward: And he was Lee's own appointee — January 2023. So this isn't a political enemy walking out. That's the governor's own guy.

Brian Reed: Which — I mean, what does that tell you about Lee's moratorium? It covers executions through the end of 2026. That's it. No public commitment about 2027 whatsoever.

Eliza Ward: So the fork is — either Tennessee schedules a second attempt and forces courts to actually rule on Pike's Eighth Amendment and double jeopardy arguments, which would set national precedent. Or political pressure just quietly produces a de facto commutation and those constitutional questions stay permanently unanswered.

Brian Reed: And the January 2027 Senate inquiry — Jack Johnson said the Senate examines protocols when it reconvenes. That's the next concrete date. But a committee reviewing protocols is not the same as commuting a sentence.

Eliza Ward: Right — but even if Pike wins the legal argument, what's the actual remedy? Because Kenneth Smith was conscious and gasping during his nitrogen gas execution in 2024. The Eighth Amendment argument did not stop it. Courts found it plausible and he was still executed, just by a different method.

Brian Reed: So the remedy might just be — nitrogen gas.

Eliza Ward: That's the part missing from every piece of coverage I've seen. No one's naming it. If Pike wins on constitutional theory, the actual next step could be a different method — not commutation. Courts haven't had to answer that yet because the Alabama cases never forced it.

Brian Reed: So watch January — Jack Johnson's Senate inquiry, and whether Lee makes any statement about 2027 executions once the moratorium expires. That's the first real signal of which fork Tennessee actually takes.

Eliza Ward: And that's the thing that won't resolve — not the legal theory, the actual fact underneath it. No prisoner has ever survived a full double dose of pentobarbital before. That's not a number courts have had to interpret. So is the punishment complete or incomplete? Because the state literally fired everything it's allowed to fire.

Brian Reed: And I don't — I mean, I keep trying to find a framework where that question gets answered, and the honest version is: it hasn't been. Courts never resolved it in Alabama. Smith and Miller were just moved to a different method before anyone had to decide. Christa Pike is the only woman on Tennessee's death row, and she's now sitting in a legal position that is genuinely — no court has mapped this territory.

Eliza Ward: And maybe never will.

Brian Reed: That's actually what I think is most unsettling. If Tennessee lets the moratorium quietly extend — no second attempt scheduled, January inquiry produces protocol revisions, political pressure accumulates — the constitutional question stays permanently theoretical. Pike's situation becomes a legal asterisk. The state never forces courts to say whether a constitutionally complete punishment can also be legally incomplete. And we just never know.

Eliza Ward: Which might be — I mean, that might be the outcome Tennessee prefers. No ruling means no precedent that constrains them. Keep it unresolved forever.