Brian Reed: Hey. Good to be back. So — this one's been sitting with me since yesterday.
Eliza Ward: Yeah, same. Reinaldo Dennes.
Brian Reed: Huntsville, November twentieth. Sixty-three minutes from when they strapped him to the gurney. He was crying out — complained about pain in his right leg, invoked God. Sixty-three minutes.
Eliza Ward: And Texas Department of Criminal Justice said staff followed state procedures throughout.
Brian Reed: Right — which is the part I don't get. Because pentobarbital is supposed to work like surgical anesthesia. Drug enters the vein, consciousness ends in seconds. That's the whole premise. Sixty-three minutes of audible pain is not a procedural hiccup — that's the premise failing.
Eliza Ward: And this is — wait, less than eight weeks after Christa Pike in Tennessee. September thirtieth. Same drug, different state, she kept breathing for forty minutes and survived.
Brian Reed: Two executions. Same single drug. Eight weeks apart. And the vein access failed both times.
Eliza Ward: But here's where I want to slow down on the pattern claim — because Pike's case has something Dennes' doesn't. She'd been diagnosed with myeloproliferative disorder. Thrombocytosis. Her own legal team flagged it before September thirtieth — said it would complicate IV access. Randy Spivey put it in a court filing: veins may have blown during attempts, drug pooled in her arms, left them burned and blistered.
Brian Reed: So the question is whether the vein failure was the disorder, or the drug.
Eliza Ward: That's exactly — wait, that's where Dr. Joel Zivot pushes back hard. He's the anesthesiologist advising Pike's defense. His argument is she had no special immunity. The drug just didn't reach her bloodstream in sufficient quantity. Full stop.
Brian Reed: Right — but Zivot's claim and the thrombocytosis aren't actually incompatible. If the veins blew because of her clotting condition, the drug pools instead of circulating. That's still 'didn't reach her bloodstream.' The mechanism just has an extra step.
Eliza Ward: Okay, that's — yeah, that's a fair read. But it matters for what we infer about Dennes. Because Texas Department of Criminal Justice said the same thing Tennessee said: staff struggled to find a vein, followed procedures. Two states, same language, same drug, same vein signature. But I genuinely don't know how many pentobarbital executions ran in those same eight weeks without an incident report. We're pointing at two visible failures and I don't have a denominator.
Brian Reed: Picture the witness room at Riverbend on September thirtieth. Pike's snoring — loudly — forty minutes after two full doses. And nobody in that room knows whether to intervene because there is literally no protocol written for that moment. Tennessee's own procedure stops at the second injection.
Eliza Ward: And that's — the 'standard procedures were followed' answer starts to collapse when you realize the procedure never wrote down what happens if both doses fail. That part we haven't gotten to yet, and it's worse than it sounds.
Brian Reed: And that's the take I want to push on — because 'procedures were followed' is circulating like it's exoneration. It's not. Tennessee's protocol has two syringes, five grams total, second dose if the first fails. That's where the written procedure ends. There is no step three. So when officials say they followed procedure, what they're actually saying is: they ran out of procedure.
Eliza Ward: Hold on — could they mean something narrower? Like, the staff did exactly what they were trained to do, they just weren't trained for this scenario?
Brian Reed: Maybe. But that's — I mean, that's actually worse, right? If the training itself has no answer for 'second dose also fails,' then following the training perfectly still leaves you in an uncharted situation. That's not a defense. That's a description of the gap.
Eliza Ward: And there's a live scientific dispute sitting underneath all of this. Gail Van Norman — internist, anesthesiologist, Adjunct Professor of Bioethics at the University of Washington — she submitted an expert declaration to the Supreme Court warning that single-drug pentobarbital risks flash pulmonary edema. If the inmate stays conscious, it's not just pain — she's describing severe suffocation. The Trump administration released a counter-report arguing a lethal dose causes unconsciousness before any of that can happen. Those two positions cannot both be right, and neither fully explains Dennes crying out for sixty-three minutes.
Brian Reed: And the speed mismatch makes it worse. Bill Lee ordered an independent review of Pike's execution — that review had not concluded when Texas executed Dennes. The accountability mechanism was literally still running.
Eliza Ward: So the question isn't just whether the protocol failed — it's whether Lee's review can reach anything before the next execution date gets set.
Brian Reed: And that's — I mean, that's the thing that keeps landing for me. Dennes was the ninth Texas execution of 2026. Ninth. The schedule doesn't pause. No mechanism existed to interrupt it after Pike survived. That's not a gap in one state's protocol — that's the system telling you it has no circuit breaker.
Eliza Ward: Right — but I genuinely can't tell if this is a drug problem, a delivery problem, or a system problem. And those aren't the same answer. If courts rule the problem is pentobarbital itself, states need an alternative drug. If it's vein access — staff training, Pike's thrombocytosis — pentobarbital stays legal and nothing about the drug changes. Those lead to completely different places and I don't think the evidence settles it yet.
Brian Reed: And even if it gets settled — the legal system just showed it can't move fast enough to matter. Bill Lee's review was still open when Texas executed Dennes. What would have to change for a court to actually stop the tenth execution while that question is still live?
Eliza Ward: I don't know. That's — wait, I genuinely don't have an answer to that. And I think that's where we are.