Onpode
Cover art for The Foreign Secretary faces renewed scrutiny over his 2016 push to overturn the Brexit referendum result

The Foreign Secretary faces renewed scrutiny over his 2016 push to overturn the Brexit referendum result

November 20, 2026 · 10 min

Eliza Ward & Brian Reed

Hey. Good week so far? Honestly, yeah — until about an hour ago when this Lammy thing started circulating again. Right, that's — okay, so here's the confirmed thing: a clip of David Lammy, June 25th 2016, two days after the Brexit referendum, telling Parliament to 'stop this madness' and reject the Leave result. That…

David Lammy, who served as the UK's Foreign Secretary under Prime Minister Keir Starmer from 2024 and was subsequently appointed Deputy Prime Minister under Starmer before Starmer's removal, is now a prominent voice urging Prime Minister Andy Burnham to pursue full EU membership for the United Kingdom.

0:009:58
Get the next episode on Britain →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on Britain →

About this episode

David Lammy, who served as the UK's Foreign Secretary under Prime Minister Keir Starmer from 2024 and was subsequently appointed Deputy Prime Minister under Starmer before Starmer's removal, is now a prominent voice urging Prime Minister Andy Burnham to pursue full EU membership for the United Kingdom.

Grounded in 9 sources
A Man for All Seasons - Harvard Law School | Harvard Law School ↗ · hls.harvard.edu
The UK and EU hold a rare summit to strengthen ties as Burnham seeks to mend Brexit damage - AP News ↗ · apnews.com
David Lammy urges Andy Burnham to take UK back into the EU - BBC News ↗ · bbc.co.uk
David Lammy urges Andy Burnham take UK back into the EU ↗ · bbc.com
Rhun ap Iorwerth says closer ties to EU will help undo Brexit 'damage' - BBC ↗ · bbc.com
Start talks to rejoin EU now, says ex-minister Peter Kyle ↗ · bbc.com
Ten years on, is the UK preparing to undo Brexit? - CNN ↗ · cnn.com
David Lammy MP urges Parliament to reject EU referendum result ↗ · independent.co.uk
Easing Back From Brexit: What to Expect at U.K. Summit With E.U. - The New York Times ↗ · nytimes.com
Read transcript

Eliza Ward: Hey. Good week so far?

Brian Reed: Honestly, yeah — until about an hour ago when this Lammy thing started circulating again.

Eliza Ward: Right, that's — okay, so here's the confirmed thing: a clip of David Lammy, June 25th 2016, two days after the Brexit referendum, telling Parliament to 'stop this madness' and reject the Leave result. That clip. It's everywhere again this week.

Brian Reed: And the timing is — hang on, let me get this right — the clip resurfaces exactly as the UK and EU are sitting down in Brussels for this summit on the 20th of November?

Eliza Ward: That's the confirmed sequence, yeah. Reform UK-aligned critics are the ones amplifying it. And the characterisation they're using is pretty specific — that Lammy 'begged parliamentary colleagues to overrule the people.'

Brian Reed: Which — I mean, he did say that. That's on record. The Independent archived it. The 2016 referendum was 51.9% Leave, over a million votes in the margin, and he wanted Parliament to — what, just set that aside?

Eliza Ward: That was the argument, yes. And now he's Deputy Prime Minister under Andy Burnham. Same person.

Brian Reed: And the government has said — nothing? No rebuttal, nothing pushing back on the clip?

Eliza Ward: No confirmed rebuttal, nothing — but that's actually not the story anymore. Because what happened this week isn't the old clip. Lammy went on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, around the 18th of November, and called on Burnham to run at the next general election on a pledge to rejoin the EU. That's the new thing.

Brian Reed: Wait — he specified terms? Like, actual terms?

Eliza Ward: He did. No Schengen, keep the pound, renegotiated budget formula. That level of detail.

Brian Reed: Okay, so — and this is the part I think the headline completely buries — in 2016 he wanted Parliament to override the voters. In 2026 he's explicitly asking for a public vote. Those are not the same mechanism. I mean, it's like a referee who tried to cancel a match the moment the final whistle blew, and is now saying 'let's play a rematch but with cleaner rules.' The move is different.

Eliza Ward: And here's the constitutional piece that actually explains why the 2016 version was so explosive. UK referendums are advisory. Parliament retains sovereignty — always has. So his 2016 call wasn't illegal. Parliament could have done it. That's precisely what made it politically toxic.

Brian Reed: So the system said 'yes, technically' and the country said 'absolutely not.'

Eliza Ward: Right. And now he's — wait, actually this is the pivot — he's moving away from that parliamentary override argument entirely. He's not saying Parliament should block anything. He's saying voters should get a fresh question. Those are constitutionally different claims.

Brian Reed: Which matters, but — the part I don't get is whether the terms he outlined, no Schengen, no euro, renegotiated rebate, whether those are actually things the EU would agree to, or whether he's just made the offer sound more negotiable than it is. Because Burnham hasn't endorsed that level of detail publicly.

Eliza Ward: That's the gap. Burnham said Brexit 'has not worked' — his words — and that all options including rejoining are on the table. But 'on the table' and Lammy's specific three-condition package are not the same commitment. One's a diagnosis, one's an offer. We don't know if the EU's signed up for either.

Brian Reed: But here's what gets buried in the diagnosis-versus-offer gap — the circulating take, the one Reform UK is running with, is 'Lammy's a hypocrite.' And I don't think that actually holds. Because what he did in 2016 and what he's doing now aren't even the same kind of move.

Eliza Ward: No, I'd go further — the hypocrisy frame is too clean. It's the wrong charge.

Brian Reed: Right, but let me test that. 2016: Parliament should override the voters. 2026: voters should get the question again. Reform UK's argument is that those are the same anti-democratic instinct wearing different clothes. Is that actually wrong?

Eliza Ward: It's wrong because it conflates the mechanism with the motive. One bypasses the public, one goes back to the public. Those are — wait, actually the harder question is whether shifting mechanism is enough. Because Lammy has never said the 2016 call was wrong. No recorded statement, no account of what changed. We have a new position. We don't have a changed mind.

Brian Reed: That's — yeah. That's the gap.

Eliza Ward: And it matters more now than it did because — he was MP for Tottenham in 2016. Now he's Deputy Prime Minister and Lord Chancellor. A Leave voter in Tottenham, sitting at a kitchen table in November 2026, watching the same guy who wanted Parliament to skip the queue now asking for a do-over — without ever saying 'I was wrong to do that' — that wound doesn't close.

Brian Reed: So the scrutiny isn't the same as 2016. The seniority multiplies it. And a government that hasn't issued any rebuttal to the clip — that silence means something different when it's the Deputy PM under fire, not a backbencher.

Eliza Ward: Exactly — and that silence question, whether it's confidence or vulnerability, is the thread that actually runs into what Burnham's doing here. Which we're going to get to — because how far Burnham has deliberately kept his distance from Lammy's specific rejoin call, and what the next election makes concrete, that sharpens things considerably.

Brian Reed: The wrong take is 'hypocrite.' The right question is — why hasn't anyone asked him directly whether June 2016 was a mistake?

Eliza Ward: And that question is exactly where the silence stops being passive. Because Burnham's 'Emperor's new clothes' speech — that's a diagnosis. Brexit hasn't worked, decade of damage, all of that. Lammy on the Today programme is a prescription. Rejoin, no Schengen, no euro, renegotiated rebate. Those are not the same thing, and the EU has not signed up for the prescription.

Brian Reed: So where does that leave the faction? Because it's not just Lammy. Rhun ap Iorwerth — Welsh First Minister — he's out there saying closer EU ties will help undo Brexit damage. Peter Kyle's saying similar things. This is — I mean, it's a cluster, not a solo act.

Eliza Ward: A faction with no official cover.

Brian Reed: Right — and that's actually the sharpest thing about Burnham's position. He's letting ap Iorwerth, Kyle, Lammy absorb the heat, keeping his own distance, while simultaneously saying all options are on the table. That's — wait, is that strategy or is it just delay?

Eliza Ward: We can't confirm which. That's the honest answer. What we can say is the November 20th summit was only the second EU-UK summit since Brexit. Second. That's — the atmospherics matter, but nobody's told us what was actually agreed in that room.

Brian Reed: So the concrete thing to watch is 2029. Does Burnham enter that election with a formal rejoin pledge or not? Because if he does — the 2016 clip is the first attack ad. Reform UK has it queued, no rebuttal has been road-tested, and Lammy is Deputy PM. That's not a background liability, that's the front page.

Eliza Ward: And if he doesn't — if 2029 is still 'closer ties, all options open' — then the faction is just noise the government tolerated without cost. The silence looks like strategy in hindsight.

Brian Reed: But that only works if nobody forces the question before 2029. The wound Lammy's carrying — no account of what changed in his head since 2016 — that stays open until someone closes it. And the government's not closing it.

Eliza Ward: Which is the signal to watch, honestly. Not whether Lammy says more — whether Burnham ever formally distances or formally endorses. Right now it's neither. And that neither is a decision.

Brian Reed: And the credibility problem doesn't stay with Lammy, that's the thing. A party asking voters to trust a new referendum — while its Deputy PM once said the last one shouldn't count — that's not just his liability. That's the Labour Party's argument to make.

Eliza Ward: Right — and his terms, no Schengen, no euro, renegotiated budget formula — those are politically attractive. But we don't actually know what was agreed at the November 20th summit. Second EU-UK summit since Brexit, and the sources give us atmosphere, not outcomes.

Brian Reed: So he could be the right argument and the wrong messenger. At the same time.

Eliza Ward: That's — yeah, actually that's where I land. The case for a second democratic process might be entirely sound. Whether the person making it can carry it without someone finally asking 'was June 2016 a mistake' — we just don't know. That question's still open.

Brian Reed: And nobody's closed it. Not Lammy, not Burnham. The summit was two days ago and we're still reading atmospherics.