Onpode
Cover art for Trump's control of the GOP is slipping—his party chair faces open rebellion after midterm defeats

Trump's control of the GOP is slipping—his party chair faces open rebellion after midterm defeats

November 16, 2026 · 9 min

Eliza Ward & Brian Reed

Hey — you read the same thing I did this morning? If it's the RNC story, yes. And honestly it took me a minute to — let me see — to actually clock what's confirmed versus what people are inferring. Okay, what's confirmed: a faction inside the Republican National Committee is formally backing KC Crosbie…

Following the Republican Party's poor performance in the November 3, 2026, midterm elections — described by multiple sources as the party's worst midterm performance in a generation — a nascent rebellion has emerged inside the Republican National Committee (RNC) against Joe Gruters, the chair personally selected by President Donald Trump.

0:008:36
Get the next episode on Donald Trump →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on Donald Trump →

About this episode

Following the Republican Party's poor performance in the November 3, 2026, midterm elections — described by multiple sources as the party's worst midterm performance in a generation — a nascent rebellion has emerged inside the Republican National Committee (RNC) against Joe Gruters, the chair personally selected by President Donald Trump.

Grounded in 5 sources
Trump's handpicked party chair faces a rebellion as midterm losses challenge president's grip on GOP - AP News ↗ · apnews.com
Trump’s handpicked party chair faces a rebellion after midterm losses test president’s grip on GOP - The Boston Globe ↗ · bostonglobe.com
Trump's handpicked GOP chair faces a rebellion after midterm landslide - Los Angeles Times ↗ · latimes.com
Trump's handpicked party chair faces a rebellion as midterm losses challenge president's grip on GOP | PBS News ↗ · pbs.org
KC Crosbie Leadership Challenge ↗ · realtruth.media
Read transcript

Eliza Ward: Hey — you read the same thing I did this morning?

Brian Reed: If it's the RNC story, yes. And honestly it took me a minute to — let me see — to actually clock what's confirmed versus what people are inferring.

Eliza Ward: Okay, what's confirmed: a faction inside the Republican National Committee is formally backing KC Crosbie to remove Joe Gruters. The chair Trump personally installed.

Brian Reed: Right after November third.

Eliza Ward: Worst Republican midterm performance in a generation. That's the trigger.

Brian Reed: So Trump goes on Truth Social, calls Gruters a 'MAGA Warrior,' full endorsement — and the faction is still moving forward anyway. That's the part that made me stop.

Eliza Ward: Yeah, the post didn't stop it. Which — that's already a signal, right? The 168-member body votes in January. Arizona. So this is live.

Brian Reed: And Crosbie is — she's already a sitting RNC officer. Vice Chair from Kentucky. This isn't someone outside the structure throwing rocks.

Eliza Ward: Right — but that's actually what makes this different from normal party infighting. Think of the RNC like a campaign's back-office operation. Whoever runs it owes their job to the president, so normally you don't rock the boat. What the midterms did — the November third losses — is they cracked that logic open. People inside the back office started asking out loud whether their boss should still be running it.

Brian Reed: And Oscar Brock just — he said it plainly, right? Out loud.

Eliza Ward: RNC member from Tennessee. He publicly said Gruters failed to pull his weight, and — this is the line that matters — the party's job is to elect Republicans broadly, not to serve one man. That's not a process complaint. That's a direct challenge to the whole premise of how Trump has used the committee.

Brian Reed: That framing — 'not to serve one man' — that's a thing you couldn't say publicly six months ago without it costing you something real.

Eliza Ward: And the leaking is — wait, that's the other signal. Factions are now leaking emails and opposition research on each other. Inside the RNC. That's not spin. That's internal discipline already fractured.

Brian Reed: Hang on — does 'small but growing' actually tell us anything? Like, is Crosbie's faction 20 votes? 60?

Eliza Ward: No confirmed vote count. That's the missing number. 'Small but growing' is not a number — and it's the number that determines whether the White House threats mean they're nervous or just being loud.

Brian Reed: So the new part is the anatomy — Brock going public, the leaking — not necessarily the conclusion that Trump's control is slipping. That's still unresolved going into Arizona.

Eliza Ward: But here's what I keep getting stuck on — the narrative that's already circulating is that the audit demands are a principled governance stand. And I'm not sure that holds.

Brian Reed: Right, that's — that's the take I want to push on. Because the specifics are real. Hair and makeup payments for Trump and other officials. A contract with Susie Wiles's daughter. These aren't invented grievances. Someone dug those out.

Eliza Ward: Auditable. Verifiable. Which is exactly the problem.

Brian Reed: Because — wait, let me think through this — if you're a Crosbie supporter building a case to flip committee members, you don't lead with ideology. You can't. That puts you directly against Trump. But a spreadsheet of expenditures? That's procedural. That's safe. The specificity of those line items is exactly what you'd want if you were assembling a dossier, not just if you genuinely wanted cleaner books.

Eliza Ward: And Gruters defending the Presidents Cup spend — $22,500 on hospitality, claims it returned $2.5 million in donor contributions — that's either a reasonable ROI argument or it's what you say when you know you're being targeted and you need a number fast.

Brian Reed: No, I don't buy that those are mutually exclusive.

Eliza Ward: Wait — no, that's actually my point. The sources don't resolve which it is. You could have a legitimate $2.5 million return and the audit call is still tactical. The hair and makeup line is real and it's also being weaponized. Those things can both be true.

Brian Reed: So imagine you're an RNC member from a swing state, you open your email Tuesday morning, there's a detailed spending breakdown you've never seen before. Are you reading that as a concerned party official — or were you already looking for a reason to vote no, and now you have one?

Eliza Ward: And that's what makes the White House fundraising threat interesting — because threatening to cut off members who don't back Gruters only works if the audit complaints are the real motive. If people have already decided and they're just using the audit as cover, the threat changes nothing. We find out which one it is in Arizona — and what that vote actually proves about Trump's hold on the party is a whole separate question we haven't gotten to yet.

Brian Reed: And that's the thing about the fundraising threat — it hasn't actually been executed yet. So right now it's just leverage held out there. Which means going into Arizona, nobody knows if the White House will actually pull it.

Eliza Ward: That's the tell. If they were confident, you don't need to threaten. You just win.

Brian Reed: Right — but hang on. Does an unexecuted threat actually cost them anything? Like, if Gruters wins, it never had to be real.

Eliza Ward: It costs them credibility if Crosbie's faction keeps growing and they still don't pull it. That's the moment — does the White House execute before January or not? That's actually the number to watch before the Arizona meeting.

Brian Reed: And the White House reportedly told Trump not to attack Crosbie personally before that Truth Social post. That detail — I mean, that's not confidence. That's anxiety about overplaying.

Eliza Ward: Both things at once — loud endorsement, restrained attack. That's not a unified posture.

Brian Reed: So say Crosbie loses — by 40 votes or whatever. Does that actually confirm Trump's control is intact? Because most elected Republican leaders haven't moved away from him at all. The 168 people in that room are committee members, not senators, not governors. What are we actually measuring?

Eliza Ward: Exactly that — committee machinery. Whoever runs the RNC controls voter targeting, candidate recruitment, the institutional posture going into 2028. That's real. But it's not — wait, it doesn't tell you about the base, it doesn't tell you about Congress. It tells you who controls the back office for the next presidential primary.

Brian Reed: So what actually moves the needle before January: does the White House execute that fundraising cutoff, and does Crosbie's count grow past whatever threshold makes the threat feel necessary? Those are the two things.

Eliza Ward: And that's — whoever wins in Arizona, we're going to get a wave of 'this proves Trump is weakening' or 'this proves he's still in control.' And it proves neither. It's 168 committee members. That's the ceiling on what this tells us.

Brian Reed: Right — and the actual test, the one that would actually settle the authority question, is what happens after January. Like, if Crosbie wins and Trump can't punish the members who voted for her — can't actually execute that fundraising cutoff — that's more revealing than the vote itself.

Eliza Ward: Wait, yes. Because threatening and not executing — that's a different story than threatening and doing it. The 2028 nominating machinery, who controls candidate recruitment, ad buying — that only matters if the chair can actually operate independently of the White House. And we don't know that yet.

Brian Reed: So the open question isn't really the vote count. It's — I mean, it's whether the fundraising threat was real leverage or just the loudest thing the White House could say before January. And we won't know until someone actually tests it.

Eliza Ward: And nobody can test it until after the vote. So — genuinely unresolved. Both outcomes.