Walt Garner: Hello, hello. You have the look of someone sitting on a question. Out with it before I start lecturing.
Nina Park: I do, yeah. There's this startup, Suno, where you type one sentence and a whole finished song comes out. And I can't stop wondering what on earth it learned from. I mean, that's the entire fight, isn't it?
Walt Garner: Now, let me give you a person instead of a principle. A session guitarist in Nashville, school pickup line, and a friend holds up a phone. She's a composite, to be clear, illustrative, not a plaintiff. The clip is a Suno song, and the guitar tone sounds like what she played in 2009.
Nina Park: Wait, but how does it make that?
Walt Garner: Picture a kid who's listened to nearly every record ever made, then writes 'new' songs in the styles they absorbed. That's generative AI for music, built from patterns in a huge pile of recordings. Whether listening that hard needed permission... that's the question.
Nina Park: And where did Suno's pile come from?
Walt Garner: Well, the recordings a system ingests to learn are called training data, and Suno told the court it trained on essentially all the music files of reasonable quality on the open internet. Tens of millions of recordings. It says that's allowed.
Nina Park: That's like confessing to eating the whole buffet while arguing tasting isn't eating. Okay, who's actually suing over this?
Walt Garner: Well, the awkward answer is that the plaintiffs aren't even on the same side anymore. Warner settled with Suno in November 2025 and announced a partnership, the first major to do it. Universal settled with Udio in October and partnered there, but it's still litigating against Suno. Sony hasn't settled with either.
Nina Park: And Warner did its own Udio deal in mid-November, so it's in on both. Yeah, and all three labels walked into court together on June 24, 2024, through the RIAA. Same lawsuit. Three different exits.
Walt Garner: Then how does Suno's co-founder square that with the fair-use filing?
Nina Park: Oh, this is my favorite part. Mikey Shulman said, quote, "We have always thought that working together with the music industry instead of against the music industry is the only way that this works." Meanwhile his own lawyers are telling a judge the training was legal, so nobody needs permission. I mean, which is it? Partner or not-needed?
Walt Garner: Could it be both? Napster, sampling, streaming. The pattern is that the disruptor fights first, then gets licensed.
Nina Park: Right, but the part that doesn't fit is who got licensed last time. Okay, here's my "wait, no." The American Federation of Musicians sued Universal and Warner over those Suno and Udio settlements. The musicians' union, suing the labels, saying musicians' interests weren't adequately protected.
Walt Garner: Hold on. The labels, who supposedly speak for artists.
Nina Park: Yeah. And Eight Mile Style, with its 269 Eminem compositions, and Reservoir, the one suing Suno and Anthropic, don't have a major's leverage to cut a deal like that. So back to her, the guitarist. Say she opens an email saying her label signed a Suno partnership. Her playing is on forty records. Does she get a line item, or a "congratulations, you're now part of the future"?
Walt Garner: Now, I suspect it turns on a contract she signed twenty years ago, before anyone imagined this. And we should say plainly that the sourcing on the settlement terms is thin. We simply don't know what's in them.
Nina Park: Twenty years ago. Yeah. And I mean, nobody can even confirm which datasets Suno actually used, so she couldn't point to her own playing if she wanted to.
Walt Garner: Quite so, and the courts haven't settled the larger question either. So what we're left with is a licensing market that may well form, and the open question is whether it pays only whoever sits at the table, or whether any of it reaches the woman in the pickup line.
Nina Park: My grandma would say, "If it's good enough to borrow, it's good enough to ask for." And I keep seeing that phone go dark in her hand, the clip ending, the line of minivans just moving forward. Nobody knows yet who gets paid.