Onpode
Cover art for William Shatner thinks CBS made a huge mistake canceling his 2010 sitcom '$#*! My Dad Says'

William Shatner thinks CBS made a huge mistake canceling his 2010 sitcom '$#*! My Dad Says'

November 22, 2026 · 7 min

Ryan Castillo & Jordan Hale

William Shatner's CBS sitcom '$#*! My Dad Says' earned a 2011 People's Choice Award and ranked in the top 20 most weeks, yet was quietly replaced in February 2011 — three months before its official May cancellation. Creator Justin Halpern called the ratings 'merely adequate by CBS standards,' while critics gave it a 0% score.

In September 2010, William Shatner debuted in his first starring role in a traditional multi-camera sitcom filmed before a live studio audience: CBS's $#*! My Dad Says.

0:006:36
Get the next episode on lost, scrapped, unaired sitcoms we will NEVER get to see →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on lost, scrapped, unaired sitcoms we will NEVER get to see →

About this episode

William Shatner thinks CBS made a mistake canceling $#*! My Dad Says, the 2010 sitcom he led at age 79. He has a case: the show won the People's Choice Award for Favorite New TV Comedy and ranked in the top 20 most weeks it aired. He also has a blind spot: a 0% critics score and ratings that Justin Halpern, who adapted his own Twitter feed for the show, described as merely adequate by CBS standards. This episode works through the gap between those two accounts. It starts with the structural problem — a Twitter feed built on surprise and bluntness, translated into a format that engineers every joke to land on a beat in front of a live audience. When you add the setup the sitcom needs, you lose the sting that made the original work. It then gets into the network logic: popular in total viewers isn't what advertisers buy. CBS was measuring demo ratings against cost against whatever else could fill that half-hour. A top 20 show can still be a losing trade. And the timeline is quietly damning — CBS moved on three months before the formal cancellation announcement. The episode doesn't flatten Shatner into someone who simply misread a spreadsheet. His regret sounds sincere, and nobody works eighteen episodes believing it's failing. But a fair verdict needs all four pieces at once: the popularity, the benchmark, the critical rejection, and the format. Drop any one and you get a cleaner story than the real one.

Frequently asked

Why was '$#*! My Dad Says' canceled if it was a top 20 show?

'$#*! My Dad Says' ranked in the top 20 most weeks but was replaced by 'Rules of Engagement' in February 2011 — three months before the formal cancellation announcement. CBS weighed Shatner's salary and production costs against a cheaper, steadier alternative. Creator Justin Halpern described the ratings as 'merely adequate by CBS standards.'

What were the ratings and reviews for '$#*! My Dad Says'?

'$#*! My Dad Says' earned a 55% audience score and a 0% critics score on review aggregators, while winning the 2011 People's Choice Award for Favorite New TV Comedy. It ranked top 20 most weeks and top 10 in Canada, but critical rejection was constant throughout its 18-episode run.

What did William Shatner say about CBS canceling '$#*! My Dad Says'?

William Shatner told Vulture, 'They shouldn't have canceled it; it was too popular,' citing top 20 rankings and top 10 performance in Canada. Shatner never mentioned the show's 0% critics score in that interview. Creator Justin Halpern offered a different view, calling the ratings adequate but not strong enough by CBS benchmarks.

What went wrong with adapting 'Shit My Dad Says' from Twitter to a TV sitcom?

Adapting 'Shit My Dad Says' — Justin Halpern's Twitter account with 1.7 million followers — into a CBS multi-camera sitcom required adding setup beats before punchlines, which diluted the blunt, brutal quality of the original tweets. Halpern acknowledged that jokes were restructured for audience timing, softening the harsh character-driven humor that made the feed popular.

Who made '$#*! My Dad Says' and what was the production setup?

'$#*! My Dad Says' was commissioned and aired by CBS, produced by Warner Bros. Television, and executive produced by David Kohan and Max Mutchnick, the creators of 'Will & Grace.' Justin Halpern and Patrick Schumacker adapted the show from Halpern's bestselling book and Twitter account. It ran for 18 episodes in 2010–2011.

Grounded in 6 sources
When Captain Kirk and Lieutenant Uhura kissed, and America was pretty okay with it - The Washington Post ↗ · washingtonpost.com
William Shatner Believes CBS Made A Big Mistake Canceling His Short ... ↗ · yahoo.com
$h*! My Dad Says ↗ · en-academic.com
$h*! My Dad Says - Wikipedia ↗ · en.wikipedia.org
$ ↗ · en.wikipedia.org
William Shatner - Wikipedia ↗ · en.wikipedia.org
Read transcript

Jordan Hale: Ryan, hey, you ready? Picture Captain Kirk, standing in front of a live studio audience, waiting for a laugh that maybe isn't coming.

Ryan Castillo: That's William Shatner, September 23, 2010, on CBS. His first multi-camera sitcom lead. Go on.

Jordan Hale: The show, $#*! My Dad Says, won the 2011 People's Choice Award for Favorite New TV Comedy. And has a 0% critics score. Zero. Audience is 55%.

Ryan Castillo: Hold on. An award winner got canceled? Why?

Jordan Hale: I mean, part of it, I think, is this. A tweet is a punchline with the setup removed. A sitcom is setup, pause, punchline, laugh. Totally different animals.

Ryan Castillo: Huh. So the source skipped the thing the format needs. And the source was big, right?

Jordan Hale: Huge. Justin Halpern's 'Shit My Dad Says' Twitter account hit 1.7 million followers, and then it became a bestselling book.

Ryan Castillo: So CBS had a hit feed and a legend. Look, on paper that's a safe bet.

Jordan Hale: Safe how, though? A feed that's basically a grumpy man yelling in 140 characters, and the safe move is a regular network sitcom? That feels backwards, you know.

Ryan Castillo: Look, count the package. CBS commissioned and aired it. Warner Bros. Television produced it. David Kohan and Max Mutchnick, the Will & Grace guys, executive produced. Justin Halpern and Patrick Schumacker adapted it. That's a proven studio and proven sitcom builders.

Jordan Hale: Okay, but proven at what?

Ryan Castillo: Multi-cam. Three walls, a live audience, jokes engineered to land on a beat. Shatner plays Dr. Edison Milford 'Dad' Goodson III, opposite Jonathan Sadowski as his son Henry. So the raw feed becomes a father and son in one living room. Reliable. Repeatable.

Jordan Hale: Wow, 'Edison Milford Goodson the Third.' That's, like, the least tweet-sounding name possible.

Ryan Castillo: Right. And that's the point. Now the bet on Shatner. What's his résumé?

Jordan Hale: Star Trek, T.J. Hooker, Boston Legal. And I mean, that's a lot of TV, but none of it waits for a laugh. He's 79, standing there after a joke, counting silence in front of a live crowd. That's a stage muscle, and I'm not sure he'd ever built it.

Ryan Castillo: But a stage muscle is trainable. Shatner's 79, sure, but Kohan and Mutchnick built Will & Grace on exactly that rhythm. So where does the rawness actually leak out? Walk me through a room.

Jordan Hale: Okay, picture a Tuesday table read. Pizza boxes, scripts with coffee rings. A writer pitches a line straight from the real dad, something blunt, a little brutal. And the room loves it. Then someone says, we need a beat before it, so the audience can see it coming.

Ryan Castillo: A setup beat.

Jordan Hale: Right, and now the line is funnier, like, technically. But it's funny the way a sitcom wants, not the way a surprise is. And you do that eighteen times, the dad on the page starts sounding like a sitcom dad.

Ryan Castillo: Justin Halpern said as much. Jokes got restructured for timing and audience response, and that limited the harsher, character-driven quality of the feed. Fine. But look at the number you opened with: a 55% audience score. If rawness were the whole story, viewers would've felt a loss. Lukewarm says the jokes just weren't landing.

Jordan Hale: Hmm. But I mean, lukewarm could be the symptom, you know? If the brutal line gets padded, the audience gets the shape of a joke without the sting. That reads as, like, fine. Not bad. Fine.

Ryan Castillo: So is that unfixable, or badly executed? Because the same format, same producers, made hits.

Jordan Hale: No idea, honestly. Maybe a tweet can't survive three walls. Maybe nobody found the right beat. And the cancellation story has a timeline wrinkle that makes this murkier, which we'll get to.

Ryan Castillo: But the murk starts with Shatner's own line. He told Vulture, 'They shouldn't have canceled it; it was too popular.' Top 20 most of the time, top 25 always, top 10 in Canada. Look, popular in total viewers isn't what advertisers buy.

Jordan Hale: Wait, so what do they buy? I mean, a top 20 show sounds like, you know, a pretty big crowd.

Ryan Castillo: Demo viewers, and what each one costs. Shatner's salary, a Kohan and Mutchnick deal, against the rating in the ages advertisers pay for. And against whatever else could fill that half-hour.

Jordan Hale: So where's the line? Justin Halpern said ratings were merely adequate by CBS standards. What does adequate even mean?

Ryan Castillo: That's the load-bearing line. Adequate means you didn't embarrass the slot, but you didn't beat the alternative either. Networks don't renew good shows. They renew the best available use of a half-hour.

Jordan Hale: Hmm. And Shatner's version is, like, 'popular' and Halpern's is 'adequate.' Same numbers, two different sentences.

Ryan Castillo: Right, and the timeline sharpens it. The 18th episode aired February 17, 2011. CBS dropped Rules of Engagement into that slot. The formal cancellation didn't come until May 15.

Jordan Hale: No way. So the real answer came three months before the announcement?

Ryan Castillo: Yes. Picture a CBS scheduler in May, spreadsheet open, one row Shatner, one row Rules of Engagement. Slightly lower rating, cheaper, steadier. Four minutes, maybe. A top 20 show can still be a losing trade.

Jordan Hale: That's kind of brutal, honestly. He's out there saying 'I don't know what happened in CBS's mind,' and it's a spreadsheet row, you know, that was already settled.

Ryan Castillo: It was settled in February, yes. But I don't want to flatten Shatner into a guy who just misread a spreadsheet.

Jordan Hale: No, I mean, that's where I land too. His regret reads as sincere to me. Nobody works eighteen episodes believing it's failing, you know? But in that Vulture interview he never mentions the 0% critics score. Not once.

Ryan Castillo: Right. Look, he's got a real piece: the People's Choice Award, top 20, top 10 in Canada. Justin Halpern has a real piece too. Ratings adequate by CBS standards, and the hostile coverage was constant. Two insiders, two partly true stories.

Jordan Hale: So Shatner says CBS miscalculated, and Halpern says it was fine but not enough.

Ryan Castillo: Both can hold. A fair verdict needs popularity, the network benchmark, the critical rejection and the format, all four together. Drop any one and you get a cleaner story than the real one.

Jordan Hale: Yeah. And I think that's a kind way to hold it. A 79-year-old tries something new, a lot of people liked it, it wasn't quite funny enough, and it wasn't cheap enough either. All of that at once, I guess.