Jordan Hale: Ryan, hey, you ready? Picture Captain Kirk, standing in front of a live studio audience, waiting for a laugh that maybe isn't coming.
Ryan Castillo: That's William Shatner, September 23, 2010, on CBS. His first multi-camera sitcom lead. Go on.
Jordan Hale: The show, $#*! My Dad Says, won the 2011 People's Choice Award for Favorite New TV Comedy. And has a 0% critics score. Zero. Audience is 55%.
Ryan Castillo: Hold on. An award winner got canceled? Why?
Jordan Hale: I mean, part of it, I think, is this. A tweet is a punchline with the setup removed. A sitcom is setup, pause, punchline, laugh. Totally different animals.
Ryan Castillo: Huh. So the source skipped the thing the format needs. And the source was big, right?
Jordan Hale: Huge. Justin Halpern's 'Shit My Dad Says' Twitter account hit 1.7 million followers, and then it became a bestselling book.
Ryan Castillo: So CBS had a hit feed and a legend. Look, on paper that's a safe bet.
Jordan Hale: Safe how, though? A feed that's basically a grumpy man yelling in 140 characters, and the safe move is a regular network sitcom? That feels backwards, you know.
Ryan Castillo: Look, count the package. CBS commissioned and aired it. Warner Bros. Television produced it. David Kohan and Max Mutchnick, the Will & Grace guys, executive produced. Justin Halpern and Patrick Schumacker adapted it. That's a proven studio and proven sitcom builders.
Jordan Hale: Okay, but proven at what?
Ryan Castillo: Multi-cam. Three walls, a live audience, jokes engineered to land on a beat. Shatner plays Dr. Edison Milford 'Dad' Goodson III, opposite Jonathan Sadowski as his son Henry. So the raw feed becomes a father and son in one living room. Reliable. Repeatable.
Jordan Hale: Wow, 'Edison Milford Goodson the Third.' That's, like, the least tweet-sounding name possible.
Ryan Castillo: Right. And that's the point. Now the bet on Shatner. What's his résumé?
Jordan Hale: Star Trek, T.J. Hooker, Boston Legal. And I mean, that's a lot of TV, but none of it waits for a laugh. He's 79, standing there after a joke, counting silence in front of a live crowd. That's a stage muscle, and I'm not sure he'd ever built it.
Ryan Castillo: But a stage muscle is trainable. Shatner's 79, sure, but Kohan and Mutchnick built Will & Grace on exactly that rhythm. So where does the rawness actually leak out? Walk me through a room.
Jordan Hale: Okay, picture a Tuesday table read. Pizza boxes, scripts with coffee rings. A writer pitches a line straight from the real dad, something blunt, a little brutal. And the room loves it. Then someone says, we need a beat before it, so the audience can see it coming.
Ryan Castillo: A setup beat.
Jordan Hale: Right, and now the line is funnier, like, technically. But it's funny the way a sitcom wants, not the way a surprise is. And you do that eighteen times, the dad on the page starts sounding like a sitcom dad.
Ryan Castillo: Justin Halpern said as much. Jokes got restructured for timing and audience response, and that limited the harsher, character-driven quality of the feed. Fine. But look at the number you opened with: a 55% audience score. If rawness were the whole story, viewers would've felt a loss. Lukewarm says the jokes just weren't landing.
Jordan Hale: Hmm. But I mean, lukewarm could be the symptom, you know? If the brutal line gets padded, the audience gets the shape of a joke without the sting. That reads as, like, fine. Not bad. Fine.
Ryan Castillo: So is that unfixable, or badly executed? Because the same format, same producers, made hits.
Jordan Hale: No idea, honestly. Maybe a tweet can't survive three walls. Maybe nobody found the right beat. And the cancellation story has a timeline wrinkle that makes this murkier, which we'll get to.
Ryan Castillo: But the murk starts with Shatner's own line. He told Vulture, 'They shouldn't have canceled it; it was too popular.' Top 20 most of the time, top 25 always, top 10 in Canada. Look, popular in total viewers isn't what advertisers buy.
Jordan Hale: Wait, so what do they buy? I mean, a top 20 show sounds like, you know, a pretty big crowd.
Ryan Castillo: Demo viewers, and what each one costs. Shatner's salary, a Kohan and Mutchnick deal, against the rating in the ages advertisers pay for. And against whatever else could fill that half-hour.
Jordan Hale: So where's the line? Justin Halpern said ratings were merely adequate by CBS standards. What does adequate even mean?
Ryan Castillo: That's the load-bearing line. Adequate means you didn't embarrass the slot, but you didn't beat the alternative either. Networks don't renew good shows. They renew the best available use of a half-hour.
Jordan Hale: Hmm. And Shatner's version is, like, 'popular' and Halpern's is 'adequate.' Same numbers, two different sentences.
Ryan Castillo: Right, and the timeline sharpens it. The 18th episode aired February 17, 2011. CBS dropped Rules of Engagement into that slot. The formal cancellation didn't come until May 15.
Jordan Hale: No way. So the real answer came three months before the announcement?
Ryan Castillo: Yes. Picture a CBS scheduler in May, spreadsheet open, one row Shatner, one row Rules of Engagement. Slightly lower rating, cheaper, steadier. Four minutes, maybe. A top 20 show can still be a losing trade.
Jordan Hale: That's kind of brutal, honestly. He's out there saying 'I don't know what happened in CBS's mind,' and it's a spreadsheet row, you know, that was already settled.
Ryan Castillo: It was settled in February, yes. But I don't want to flatten Shatner into a guy who just misread a spreadsheet.
Jordan Hale: No, I mean, that's where I land too. His regret reads as sincere to me. Nobody works eighteen episodes believing it's failing, you know? But in that Vulture interview he never mentions the 0% critics score. Not once.
Ryan Castillo: Right. Look, he's got a real piece: the People's Choice Award, top 20, top 10 in Canada. Justin Halpern has a real piece too. Ratings adequate by CBS standards, and the hostile coverage was constant. Two insiders, two partly true stories.
Jordan Hale: So Shatner says CBS miscalculated, and Halpern says it was fine but not enough.
Ryan Castillo: Both can hold. A fair verdict needs popularity, the network benchmark, the critical rejection and the format, all four together. Drop any one and you get a cleaner story than the real one.
Jordan Hale: Yeah. And I think that's a kind way to hold it. A 79-year-old tries something new, a lot of people liked it, it wasn't quite funny enough, and it wasn't cheap enough either. All of that at once, I guess.