Onpode
Cover art for Before print, history was oral tradition and hand-copied fragments—print made it reproducible

Before print, history was oral tradition and hand-copied fragments—print made it reproducible

November 19, 2026 · 13 min

Eleanor Crane & Ben Okonkwo

Eleanor — rough week or a good one, I genuinely cannot tell from your face. Interesting week. I picked up something I thought I understood and it turned out I had the story backwards. Okay, that I want to hear. The printing press. We have this — well, this clean inherited story. Johannes Gutenberg, Mainz,…

Johannes Gutenberg developed a movable-type printing press in Mainz, Germany, around 1450–1455, an innovation that transformed how written information was reproduced, preserved, and circulated. A legal dispute in 1455 between Gutenberg and his financier Johann Fust resulted in Fust and Peter Schöffer continuing the printing enterprise.

0:0012:38
Get the next episode on History →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on History →

About this episode

Johannes Gutenberg developed a movable-type printing press in Mainz, Germany, around 1450–1455, an innovation that transformed how written information was reproduced, preserved, and circulated. A legal dispute in 1455 between Gutenberg and his financier Johann Fust resulted in Fust and Peter Schöffer continuing the printing enterprise.

Grounded in 8 sources
The Clergy and Print in Eighteenth-Century England, c. 1714-1750 ↗ · doi.org
News Networks in Early Modern Europe ↗ · doi.org
The Information Age and the Printing Press: Looking Backward to See Ahead | RAND ↗ · rand.org
Framing the debate (I). Historical Discourses: The Struggle for Both the Past and Future of the Book – OPEN REFLECTIONS ↗ · openreflections.wordpress.com
[PDF] THE PRINTING PRESS AS AN AGENT OF CHANGE ↗ · api.pageplace.de
How the Printing Press Transformed Knowledge and Power ↗ · brewminate.com
How the Printing Press Weaponized Propaganda ↗ · brewminate.com
Printing Press - Invented, Gutenberg, Significance | HISTORY ↗ · history.com
Read transcript

Ben Okonkwo: Eleanor — rough week or a good one, I genuinely cannot tell from your face.

Eleanor Crane: Interesting week. I picked up something I thought I understood and it turned out I had the story backwards.

Ben Okonkwo: Okay, that I want to hear.

Eleanor Crane: The printing press. We have this — well, this clean inherited story. Johannes Gutenberg, Mainz, Germany, movable type, somewhere around 1450 to 1455, and it's the moment history becomes reliable. That's the story. And the part that doesn't survive a second look is that the first printed books were often wrong. Errors locked in place. Pirated editions. Unauthorized copies of copies. And they were trusted more — not less — than the manuscripts they replaced.

Ben Okonkwo: More trusted despite being less accurate.

Eleanor Crane: Because of what Adrian Johns calls mechanical regularity. The uniformity of the page reads as authority — whether the content earned that authority or not.

Ben Okonkwo: So print made persuasive misinformation and systematic verification possible at the exact same moment. That's — hm, that's a genuinely uncomfortable thing to sit with, actually.

Eleanor Crane: It is. And it sets up this real tension between two historians — Eisenstein arguing that print was the structural cause of modern knowledge-building, and Johns pushing back and saying no, you're giving the machine too much credit. The question I want us to work through is which of them is right, or whether that's even the right question to be asking.

Ben Okonkwo: Right — and I think the reason the Eisenstein-Johns debate matters is that it's not just about the fifteenth century. It's about how we understand any new information technology. What the tool does versus what people build on top of it.

Eleanor Crane: Now that's the thread. And I want to follow it all the way through.

Ben Okonkwo: But before we can even get to that debate — I want to back up one step, because I think there's a structural problem underneath all of it that's easy to miss. Imagine you and a neighbor both own handwritten copies of the same chronicle. Different monks copied them, decades apart, different scriptoria. You have no way to know whether your copy matches theirs. Not even in principle.

Eleanor Crane: And that's not bad luck. That's just how the system worked.

Ben Okonkwo: Exactly that. Every copy made by hand introduced the possibility of error — a misread word, a skipped line, a scribe who thought he knew better and smoothed something out. And those small changes accumulated. Textual drift, it's called. Across generations of copying, the text that arrives at the fifteenth century might be meaningfully different from what was first written down, and nobody can necessarily tell.

Eleanor Crane: But medieval societies were keeping records. Monasteries had archives, courts had chronicles — it's not like knowledge was just floating loose.

Ben Okonkwo: No, right, that's — this is the thing I want to be precise about, because the sloppy version of the story says print created record-keeping, and that's just not true. The problem wasn't records existing. It was records being verifiable at a distance. Having an archive in one monastery tells you nothing about whether the archive in a monastery two hundred miles away says the same thing.

Eleanor Crane: Distribution and cross-checking. Those are the missing pieces.

Ben Okonkwo: And cost. Books in manuscript culture were — I mean, extraordinarily expensive. Confined mostly to monasteries and elite courts. So even if a scholar wanted to compare two copies of a text, he might never physically access both. The knowledge existed, but it existed in isolated pockets that couldn't talk to each other.

Eleanor Crane: So what you're describing is fragility that's baked into the structure — not a failure of effort or care.

Ben Okonkwo: That's the core of it, yes. A conscientious scribe doing everything right still produces a copy that diverges — maybe slightly, maybe significantly — from the original. Physical decay accelerates that. A flooded archive, a fire, an invasion. The whole manuscript culture is — it's inherently lossy.

Eleanor Crane: And there's a person inside that lossiness, which is worth pausing on. A monk in, say, 1480, spending years copying a biblical commentary — he's the entire infrastructure. His attention, his health, his theological assumptions — all of that is shaping the text.

Ben Okonkwo: And once it's copied, there's no mechanism to catch what he got wrong. That's what typographical fixity actually solves — not quality, but the ability to compare. When two people hold copies from the same printed edition, they hold the same errors, yes, but at least they can argue about the same text.

Eleanor Crane: Which is — well, that's a quieter revolution than the one we usually tell. Not truth. Just shared reference.

Ben Okonkwo: And that phrase — shared reference — that's actually the technical thing Eisenstein is building toward. She calls it typographical fixity. The property isn't just that print is fast. It's that every copy of a given edition is literally identical. Same page, same word, same line break. Which means — okay, imagine a scholar in Cologne and a scholar in Florence, 1480, both holding copies of the same printed Bible. For the first time, they can correspond about a specific discrepancy and know they're looking at the same text. That has never been structurally possible before.

Eleanor Crane: And the monk holding that printed Bible next to his own handwritten copy — that moment stands out to me. Three decades after Mainz. He has spent years on his manuscript. The exactness, the care. And he looks at the printed page and realizes — his copy is now the one that might be wrong.

Ben Okonkwo: The unreliable document is his.

Eleanor Crane: His decades of labor just became — well, evidence of drift rather than evidence of care.

Ben Okonkwo: That's what Eisenstein means by the structural shift. Standardization, dissemination, preservation — those three functions together. And McLuhan saw the outline of this in 1962, The Gutenberg Galaxy, before Eisenstein built the full empirical case. But Eisenstein in 1979 is the one who actually traced the causal chain — print to Reformation, print to Scientific Revolution, print to the conditions that make modern historiography possible.

Eleanor Crane: So what actually spread it? Because the technology existed in Mainz — and then it didn't stay in Mainz.

Ben Okonkwo: Right — and this is the part that, I mean, it's not the smooth technology-rolls-out story at all. 1455: Johann Fust, who was Gutenberg's financier, sues him. Wins. Takes the equipment. And Fust partners with Peter Schöffer, Gutenberg's own assistant, and they carry on the enterprise. So the first act of print distribution is a lawsuit.

Eleanor Crane: A financier suing the inventor and walking out with the press.

Ben Okonkwo: And then 1462 — political upheaval in Mainz. The city convulses, and the skilled printers scatter. They take the knowledge with them across Europe. By 1500, the close of what's called the incunable era, European presses had produced millions of copies across thousands of editions. That's not a technology rollout — that's a diaspora.

Eleanor Crane: It was chaos — human, political, financial chaos — that distributed the press. Not inevitability.

Ben Okonkwo: Which is — yeah, that actually complicates Eisenstein a little, doesn't it? If the technology needed a lawsuit and a city in crisis to spread, then the medium didn't drive itself.

Eleanor Crane: And that's exactly the gap Johns is pointing at. Though — the part of this story we haven't touched yet is what happens when fixity and wide distribution combine with unreliable source material. Because that's genuinely uncomfortable.

Ben Okonkwo: The same property that makes verification possible also makes a locked-in error look like settled truth.

Eleanor Crane: Across five editions, simultaneously, in cities that have never met. And the clergy — who I'd assumed were resisting this — were actually driving it. That's the part that reframes almost everything.

Ben Okonkwo: Wait — the clergy were driving it? I had them positioned as the resistant institution, the one print was working around.

Eleanor Crane: That's the inherited picture. And it's wrong. Religious institutions were actively commissioning printed texts, funding presses, using the trade to circulate devotional material at a scale manuscript culture simply couldn't reach. They saw the tool and they used it.

Ben Okonkwo: Which means the aura-of-authority problem is — I mean, that's not a secular problem, that's everybody's problem simultaneously.

Eleanor Crane: Exactly. And this is where Johns becomes — well, genuinely unsettling rather than just a corrective. Because his argument isn't that print was bad. It's that the same mechanical regularity that made verification structurally possible also made a printed error look indistinguishable from a printed fact. The page doesn't know the difference.

Ben Okonkwo: Okay but doesn't that make print sound purely negative? Like — net loss?

Eleanor Crane: No — and this is the precise thing. Print is structurally neutral. It amplifies whatever you feed it. Accurate scholarship, locked error, propaganda — same mechanism, same visual authority, no signal to the reader about which is which.

Ben Okonkwo: Uniform reproduction as a kind of — moral blind spot baked into the format.

Eleanor Crane: Put it this way. A printer in 1510 picks up a manuscript to set in type. The manuscript has a scribal error — a small one, a misread Greek term in a medical text, say. He doesn't know it's wrong. He sets it. The press runs. Five identical editions go out across Europe, Cologne, Venice, Lyon, all carrying the same wrong term. Now every physician who reads it has the same confident, uniform, authoritative wrong answer. That's not a failure of print. That's print working perfectly.

Ben Okonkwo: And the error is now harder to dislodge than a manuscript error would have been, because — right, because it's in five cities simultaneously, all looking identical.

Eleanor Crane: Piracy made it worse. Joad Raymond and Noah Moxham, in their 2016 work on news networks in early modern Europe, document exactly this — print amplified both accurate and inaccurate content at scale, and unauthorized editions meant readers genuinely could not distinguish a legitimate text from a corrupted one. Both looked the same. That's the aura Johns is naming.

Ben Okonkwo: Did anyone notice this was happening at the time? I mean — was there a contemporary critique?

Eleanor Crane: Some did. But the institutional response — the checking, the citation practices, the cross-referencing that eventually made scholarship actually reliable — that came later, and slowly. Johns's whole counter-thesis is that standardization wasn't automatic. Scholars and institutions had to build those practices on top of print, it didn't emerge from the technology itself.

Ben Okonkwo: So the medium was necessary but — not sufficient. The humans had to close the gap the machine left open.

Eleanor Crane: And that gap — the distance between what print made possible and what institutions actually built — that's where the story of modern historiography really lives. Because verification didn't come with the press. It had to be invented separately, on top of it.

Ben Okonkwo: And that's — I mean, that's the Eisenstein-Johns debate compressed into one sentence, isn't it. Print provided the infrastructure. Scholars had to build the discipline on top of it. Neither of them is wrong, they're just describing different layers of the same thing.

Eleanor Crane: Which is probably why it's still unresolved. The medium versus institution question doesn't have a clean answer because both things are true simultaneously — and depending on which layer you're standing in, the other one looks like a footnote.

Ben Okonkwo: What actually settled for me, working through all of this, is something smaller than either thesis. Print didn't give us truth. It gave us the infrastructure to argue about truth collectively — across identical copies that everyone could check. And that collective argument, done rigorously enough, over long enough, is what we eventually called historiography.

Eleanor Crane: And we're inside that same structural moment again. Scale, uniformity, mechanical reproduction — just digital now, not typographical. The conditions Eisenstein described are back, at a different order of magnitude.

Ben Okonkwo: And so is the Johns problem. The aura of authority, the locked-in error that looks indistinguishable from settled fact — that didn't go away when the press went digital. If anything it got faster.

Eleanor Crane: Which means the question the first printing era leaves us with is — which outcome did we build? The verification, or the more convincing lie. And I don't think we knew the answer in 1510, and I'm not sure we know it now.

Ben Okonkwo: Probably both, again.

Eleanor Crane: Probably both. At the same time. Same mechanism. That feels like an honest place to stop — not because it's tidy, but because it isn't.