Onpode
Cover art for Brown University found that relativity changes how heavy atoms form triple bonds

Brown University found that relativity changes how heavy atoms form triple bonds

November 22, 2026 · 8 min

Mark Delaney

On July 9, 2026, Brown University and Washington State University researchers published direct experimental evidence in Science that the carbon–bismuth anion CBi⁻ does not form a standard triple bond. Relativistic effects and spin–orbit coupling blend the sigma and pi orbitals together — the first spectroscopic proof of a prediction made in the 1970s.

A study published in the journal Science on July 9, 2026, led by chemists at Brown University in collaboration with Washington State University, provides the first direct experimental evidence that Einstein's theory of special relativity fundamentally alters the structure of chemical triple bonds in heavy elements.

0:008:22
Get the next episode on Science →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on Science →

About this episode

In July 2026, a team at Brown University and Washington State University published a paper in Science with direct experimental evidence that the triple bond in a carbon–bismuth anion called CBi⁻ doesn't work the way chemistry textbooks describe. The standard model — one sigma bond plus two pi bonds — breaks down at bismuth. The reason is relativistic: bismuth's nucleus is so strongly charged that its bonding electrons accelerate to a meaningful fraction of the speed of light, warping the electron orbitals in ways Einstein's special relativity predicts. Then spin–orbit coupling blends the sigma and pi bond types together until they're no longer cleanly separable. The episode works through what that actually means and, just as importantly, what it doesn't. Theorists flagged relativistic effects in heavy elements back in the 1970s — this finding isn't a surprise to specialists. What's new is the proof: photoelectron spectroscopy giving a direct measurement of the orbital collapse, not just a theoretical prediction. The episode also sits honestly with what's still open. CBi⁻ is one molecule. Whether the same breakdown shows up across other heavy-element triple bonds hasn't been established. And the practical stakes — bismuth as a non-toxic lead substitute in solar cells and quantum materials — remain speculative until the science catches up. What makes this worth your time isn't a headline claim. It's a clear look at how experimental confirmation works, why the gap between prediction and proof matters, and what it would mean if CBi⁻ turns out to be first rather than just weird.

Frequently asked

What did Brown University discover about bismuth triple bonds?

Brown University and Washington State University researchers reported in Science on July 9, 2026, that the carbon–bismuth anion CBi⁻ does not form a conventional triple bond. Relativistic effects cause bismuth's bonding electrons to travel at a significant fraction of the speed of light, and spin–orbit coupling merges the sigma and pi bond types inseparably.

How does Einstein's relativity affect chemical bonding in heavy elements?

In heavy elements like bismuth, the strong nuclear charge pulls bonding electrons to speeds that are a significant fraction of the speed of light. At those speeds, special relativity alters the shape and energy of electron orbitals, and spin–orbit coupling then blends sigma and pi bond types together — breaking the standard textbook model of triple bonds.

What is photoelectron spectroscopy and how was it used in the CBi⁻ study?

Photoelectron spectroscopy fires photons at a molecule and measures the energy of electrons knocked loose. The Brown and Washington State University team used it to obtain direct spectroscopic evidence that the sigma and pi bond types in CBi⁻ are genuinely merged — confirming experimentally, for the first time, what theorists had predicted since the 1970s.

Who led the Brown University bismuth bonding research?

Lai-Sheng Wang, professor of chemistry at Brown University, was the corresponding author on the July 2026 Science paper about relativistic effects on the CBi⁻ triple bond. Wang stated: 'We show direct spectroscopic evidence that what we learned in high school about chemical bonding isn't true in heavy elements.'

Does the CBi⁻ finding mean all chemistry textbooks are wrong about triple bonds?

The classical sigma-plus-two-pi triple bond model is not universally wrong — it was designed for lighter elements like carbon and nitrogen. The 2026 Brown University finding shows the model breaks down specifically for heavy elements like bismuth, where relativistic effects apply. Whether the same orbital collapse occurs across all heavy-element triple bonds remains unconfirmed.

Grounded in 4 sources
Einstein’s relativity rules chemical bonds in heavy elements, new research shows | Brown University ↗ · brown.edu
Relativity Disrupts Triple Bond Rules in Heavy Elements - Newsy Today ↗ · newsy-today.com
Researchers get first look at how relativity alters a chemical bond | Office of Research | Washington State University ↗ · research.wsu.edu
Einstein’s relativity just upended a fundamental rule of chemistry - Science Daily ↗ · sciencedaily.com
Read transcript

Mark Delaney: There's this thing that happens in bismuth — element 83 — where the electrons bonding to other atoms are moving so fast that Einstein's relativity starts, like, bending the rules of chemistry.

Mark Delaney: And I mean that literally.

Mark Delaney: July 9, 2026 — researchers at Brown University and Washington State University publish a paper in Science confirming, with direct experimental evidence, that the triple bond in a carbon–bismuth anion called CBi⁻ does not work the way every chemistry textbook says it should.

Mark Delaney: The textbook says a triple bond is one sigma bond plus two pi bonds. Clean. Separate. Distinct.

Mark Delaney: In CBi⁻, that whole framework just… collapses.

Mark Delaney: Here's why — bismuth's nucleus has such a strong positive charge that it pulls its own bonding electrons up to a significant fraction of the speed of light.

Mark Delaney: And at that speed, special relativity — Einstein's special relativity — changes the shape and the energy of those electron orbitals.

Mark Delaney: Then this quantum effect, spin–orbit coupling, kicks in hard, and it mixes the sigma and pi bond types together until you can't cleanly separate them anymore.

Mark Delaney: The bond turns into something the classical model genuinely can't hold.

Mark Delaney: What the team at Brown used to see this — and I mean actually see it, not just infer it — was photoelectron spectroscopy. You fire photons at the molecule, you measure the electrons that get knocked loose, and the energy signatures tell you what the bonding structure actually looked like.

Mark Delaney: And what it looked like? Not sigma plus two pi.

Mark Delaney: Now — theoretical chemists have been saying something like this would happen in heavy elements since the 1970s. I mean, that idea's been around for roughly fifty years.

Mark Delaney: But this is the first time anyone's gotten direct spectroscopic proof that a triple bond's orbital structure actually breaks down this way.

Mark Delaney: Fifty years to close that gap.

Mark Delaney: Lai-Sheng Wang — he's a professor of chemistry at Brown, the corresponding author on this paper — and he didn't soften it.

Mark Delaney: He said, quote, 'We show direct spectroscopic evidence that what we learned in high school about chemical bonding isn't true in heavy elements.'

Mark Delaney: Think about the weight of that. This guy studies bonding for a living, and his takeaway is — yeah, what we teach kids in school? Not true. Not for elements like bismuth.

Mark Delaney: That's the paper. And it's worth sitting with why it took this long to prove.

Mark Delaney: Now, here's where I want to be honest with you — because there's a version of this story that oversells it, and I think that version does more harm than good.

Mark Delaney: The specialists — the people who've been working in heavy-element chemistry for decades — they were not shocked by this. Wang himself said it: 'This idea that relativity is important in heavy elements has been around since the 1970s.' Fifty years. This is not a bolt from the blue.

Mark Delaney: So the discovery isn't the idea. The discovery is the proof.

Mark Delaney: And that distinction — confirmation versus surprise — it actually matters. Because what photoelectron spectroscopy gave the Brown and Washington State team wasn't a new hypothesis. It was the first direct experimental evidence that the orbital collapse in CBi⁻ is real. That the sigma and pi bond types in that anion are genuinely blended by spin–orbit coupling, in a way you can measure, not just predict on paper.

Mark Delaney: Fifty years between 'we think this happens' and 'we can show you it happens.'

Mark Delaney: That gap is worth something.

Mark Delaney: But I also want to flag something — Hacker News picked this up, 416 points, 196 comments, and one commenter made a point I think is worth naming. The relativity explanation for why mercury's liquid at room temperature? That framing — it 'may be part of the story, but it isn't the whole thing, since other heavy elements are not liquid at room temperature.' And that's a real caveat. Reaching for relativistic effects as a catch-all for weird heavy-element behavior is a shortcut, and honestly, it can be a sloppy one.

Mark Delaney: CBi⁻ is one molecule. One anion. Generalizing that to all heavy-element triple bonds — that hasn't been established yet.

Mark Delaney: And the textbook model — the sigma plus two pi thing — it was never built for bismuth. It was built for carbon, nitrogen, the lighter stuff. So the rule isn't wrong universally. It just was never designed to reach this far down the periodic table.

Mark Delaney: So 'the textbook is wrong' is a shortcut too. A useful one for a headline. Less useful if you actually want to understand what's going on.

Mark Delaney: What IS true is that the model breaks down at bismuth — and now we've got direct spectroscopic evidence of exactly how. That's the thing that moves the field.

Mark Delaney: On a practical level — because bismuth isn't just a curiosity. It's under active investigation as a non-toxic substitute for lead in next-generation solar cells. Quantum materials research. Catalytic design. The implications are real, they're just — speculative right now. There's no experimental validation timeline. I want to be clear about that.

Mark Delaney: But understanding how bismuth actually bonds at the quantum level — that's not nothing. If you're trying to engineer a material around it, you probably want to know the bonding model you learned in school doesn't apply.

Mark Delaney: So the finding in Science on July 9th isn't the end of something. It's more like — finally, solid ground under an idea that's been floating around for half a century. And that's a different kind of important than 'nobody saw this coming.' Maybe quieter. But I'd argue it's more durable.

Mark Delaney: And look — after sitting with this for a while, the CBi⁻ result is real. The photoelectron spectroscopy is direct. That part's closed. But the question that isn't closed — the one I keep turning over — is whether this is bismuth specifically, or whether it's the opening move of something bigger.

Mark Delaney: Because CBi⁻ is one molecule. One anion. And the honest thing to say is that nobody's shown yet whether the same sigma–pi orbital collapse, that same spin–orbit coupling blending the bond types together, shows up in other heavy-element triple bonds. That's the actual open question. Not a date, not a vote — just, does this generalize?

Mark Delaney: If other labs go looking — at other heavy-element triple bonds, further down the periodic table, same kind of spectroscopic setup — and they find the same collapse? Then 'textbook exception' isn't the right frame anymore. It becomes the beginning of a rewrite for the whole heavy end of the table. And that's a different kind of story. That's not one weird anion. That's a pattern.

Mark Delaney: And the stakes on that aren't just academic — kinda. If you're trying to build next-generation solar cells using bismuth as a non-toxic lead substitute, understanding how bismuth ACTUALLY bonds at the quantum level, not how the textbook says it should, that matters for the engineering. For catalytic design. For quantum materials. You need the right model to build the right thing.

Mark Delaney: Oh, and worth noting — ScienceDaily, Newsy Today, they were still circulating this story as recently as late November 2026. That's roughly four months after the July 9th publication in Science. So it's not breaking news. The paper isn't fresh. But it's still live, still moving through aggregators, which tells you something about how much headroom the conversation still has. The field hasn't settled it yet.

Mark Delaney: So the watch item is replication. Generalization. Whether what Lai-Sheng Wang and the teams at Brown and Washington State University found in CBi⁻ turns out to be bismuth being weird — or bismuth being first. That conditional is everything. If the bond collapse is everywhere down there… man, the bottom of the periodic table starts looking like a different kind of chemistry altogether.

Mark Delaney: And look — the reason I keep chewing on the 'exception becoming a rule' framing is that it only takes a handful of replications to flip it. One lab finds the same sigma–pi collapse in a different heavy-element triple bond, then another does, and suddenly CBi⁻ isn't the weird one. It's the first confirmed case in a whole class of bonds that the textbook model was never built to describe. That's not a small shift. That's the bottom of the periodic table asking for a different kind of chemistry.

Mark Delaney: Einstein's special relativity reshaping a chemical bond — that used to be a theoretical prediction. Now it's a measured result, sitting in Science, with Lai-Sheng Wang's name on it. The exception is real. Whether it's still an exception… that's the part nobody's settled yet.

Brown University found that relativity changes how heavy atoms form triple bonds · Onpode