Brian Reed: Hey. So John Williams — New York Fed president, permanent FOMC vote — he was at the UC Berkeley Alumni Salon in New York last night, and he said inflation is, quote, 'far too high' and 'stubbornly persistent.' That's the news.
Eliza Ward: And the CME FedWatch moved to ninety-three percent. Overnight.
Brian Reed: Ninety-three percent probability of a December hike — that's as of November 13. Which, hang on, that's not just traders reacting to a speech. That's traders reacting to a specific phrase. 'Still has work to do.' 'Need to take actions over time.' He didn't say how much, he didn't name a number—
Eliza Ward: Right — but Mortgage Professional America framed this specifically for brokers. Like, this speech landed in their trade press as a rate-lock signal. That's different from the usual Fed communication cycle.
Brian Reed: Different how, exactly? Because brokers hear Fed speeches all the time and mostly ignore them.
Eliza Ward: Because Williams is the Vice Chair of the FOMC. His permanent vote means — wait, actually it's not just the vote. It's that the New York Fed tends to track the committee's center. When he shifts, it usually reflects something real moving internally.
Brian Reed: So the MPA read isn't wrong. It's just... is it confirmed or is it inference at this point?
Eliza Ward: The speech is confirmed. The ninety-three percent is confirmed. What it means for the December 8–9 FOMC meeting — that's where we have to be careful.
Brian Reed: But here's the part that breaks the clean version — Williams in September, Buffalo speech, said 'there is no need for urgency.' That's the same guy. Six weeks later he's at the UC Berkeley Alumni Salon saying inflation is stubbornly persistent. So the posture shift is real. But he still didn't name a number. He didn't say 25, he didn't say 50, he didn't say when it ends.
Eliza Ward: Right — and that gap is exactly what traders ran through.
Brian Reed: So the 93% — is that Williams's commitment or the market's inference?
Eliza Ward: The market's inference. Full stop. Think of it like a landlord who tells tenants 'rents are going up' — doesn't say by how much, doesn't say when. The tenants immediately assume the worst number. Williams said 'we still have work to do.' Traders heard a specific path. Those aren't the same thing.
Brian Reed: And FXStreet Speechtracker put the November 13 remarks at 7 out of 10. Historical average is 6.1. So moderately hawkish — not off-the-charts hawkish.
Eliza Ward: Which — wait, that's the tell. 7 out of 10 is above baseline, but it's not a 9. The market priced it like a 9. That's the overread.
Brian Reed: So what did he actually commit to? Like, stripped down.
Eliza Ward: He committed to the direction. Not the magnitude — terminal rate, open. Number of hikes, open. December 8–9 is the next concrete moment, and even that, I mean — he explicitly left it unspecified. The permanent FOMC vote matters because it signals committee gravity, not because it telegraphs a number.
Brian Reed: So the signal is real, the market just filled in a blank he deliberately left empty.
Eliza Ward: Right — and that blank is exactly where the 50-basis-point take breaks down. Because October CPI technically hit Waller's threshold. Headline up 0.4 month-over-month, core up 0.3 — he said on the record, before the report, that 0.3 or above should put 50bp on the table. The number arrived. So where's the 50bp coalition?
Brian Reed: That's the take I want to push on. Everyone's reading October CPI and saying jumbo hike is live. But the hawks — the actual hawks — aren't there.
Brian Reed: Beth Hammack, Lorie Logan, Neel Kashkari. The hardliners. And they're all saying — I mean, the signals are pointing toward smaller steps, not bigger. ABN AMRO published November 11, looked at the same CPI print, and said it seals the December hike but specifically not a 50bp move. Their reason: no second-round wage dynamics. UBS same week, base case is 25 in December, 25 in March. So you've got Waller floating 50, the data technically crossing his line — and the people who should be charging that hill are... not charging.
Eliza Ward: Wait — Hammack and Logan are hawkish dissenters saying go slow?
Brian Reed: That's the thing. Susan Collins over at Boston Fed flagged increased likelihood inflation stays notably above 2%. That's hawkish language. But even that isn't an endorsement of acceleration. It's — actually, I think this is the real answer — they don't want to look panicked. A 50bp move right now reads as the Fed overreacting to one month's number.
Eliza Ward: So the constraint isn't the data. It's the narrative around the data.
Brian Reed: Right — and Waller's threshold gets you to 50 on the numbers, but the committee's reading the optics. A jumbo move implies the September pause was a mistake. No one wants to say that out loud.
Eliza Ward: And brokers are advising clients right now based on a 25-versus-50 fog that the committee itself hasn't cleared — which, what that means for anyone locking a rate before December 8, that's the part we need to get into.
Brian Reed: And that fog has a dollar figure attached to it right now. Think about someone sitting at a closing table in Denver — couple, 60-day lock, rate decision eight days out. Their broker has to give them an answer today.
Eliza Ward: Lock or float.
Brian Reed: Lock or float. And the broker's working with — I mean, what does the broker actually have? A 93% December hike probability on CME FedWatch. A 67% January 2027 probability on top of that. And a 50bp wild card that the data technically supports but the committee probably won't pull.
Eliza Ward: Wait — the 67% January number. That's the piece that hasn't landed yet. Because that's not a December problem. That's a problem for anyone locking beyond December 8.
Brian Reed: Exactly. Williams left the door open on 2027 without naming a terminal rate. So a 60-day lock takes you past December, possibly into January FOMC territory — that 67% is live unpriced risk for that borrower.
Eliza Ward: And the bond market already moved before Williams said a word. The 10-year hit near 5% — that was an 11 basis point jump on the day the October CPI dropped. So the question for that Denver broker is: is locking now paying for a move that already happened, or hedging against January?
Brian Reed: That's — yeah, that's the actual conversation. Because a Fed hike doesn't mechanically move a 30-year mortgage rate one-for-one. But Williams's signal pushes bond yields, MBS spreads, lender pricing — all of that moves before the vote. So the 10-year near 5% isn't just a headline, it's already in the quote that couple is seeing.
Eliza Ward: So float is a bet that the FOMC comes in at 25, Williams's hawkishness doesn't extend the yield move, and January doesn't materialize. That's three things that have to go right.
Brian Reed: And the December 8–9 meeting is what resolves the 25-versus-50 fog — not Williams. That's the concrete date the broker is actually waiting on, and right now they don't have it.
Eliza Ward: And even December 8–9 doesn't close it. Williams left the terminal rate genuinely open — not 'open' as a talking point, actually unspecified. So the FOMC meeting tells you 25 or 50, it doesn't tell you whether January's 67% materializes or whether this thing runs into 2027.
Brian Reed: That's the fork in the road here. If energy prices normalize, if demand softens enough in late Q4 — the people who locked early on Williams's signal look like they paid a premium for a threat that cooled. But if services inflation stays sticky, the same broker looks prescient. And we don't — I mean, the Fed doesn't know which one it is either.
Eliza Ward: Wait — that's the part that actually bothers me. The market is pricing cooling. 93% December hike, then the implied path softens. But Williams's signal assumes it won't cool. The Fed and the market are running opposite bets simultaneously.
Brian Reed: Both can't be right.
Eliza Ward: December 8–9 starts to answer it — but only the 25-or-50 question. The 2027 question? That's still open. Genuinely open.