Brian Reed: Hey — glad you're here because I genuinely don't know what to do with this morning's read.
Eliza Ward: The CPI or the market reaction to it?
Brian Reed: The gap between the two, actually. The Bureau of Labor Statistics puts out October CPI — 0.4% overall, 0.3% core — and those both beat expectations. And then Kalshi is sitting at 89% for a 25-basis-point hike. Which, hang on, isn't that the smaller move?
Eliza Ward: It is. And — wait, the Waller piece is the part you have to put next to that. He gave a speech in London on November 10th, said a 50-basis-point hike should be on the table if core came in around 0.3%. Core came in at exactly 0.3%.
Brian Reed: He called his own shot.
Eliza Ward: Called it, data confirmed it — and the market priced it at roughly 10% odds. That's what I keep returning to.
Brian Reed: So what does it mean that traders effectively ignored a Fed governor's stated threshold? Like, is that the market being efficient, or is that the market knowing something about the December 8th and 9th meeting that Waller's public comments don't reflect?
Eliza Ward: That's the question. And I don't think we can answer it cleanly yet.
Brian Reed: And here's the part that actually complicates that — the PPI came out November 13th, the day after, and it came in below forecast. 0.3% month-over-month against a 0.4% expectation. So the producer side is actually running a little cooler than predicted.
Eliza Ward: Wait — so the headline read is 'inflation is hot everywhere' and the PPI is actually a miss?
Brian Reed: Right. Which means the 'everything is hotter' story is — I mean, it's not exactly wrong, but it's not the full picture either. Goods and services are behaving differently, and we're kind of collapsing them into one narrative.
Eliza Ward: And then pile on top of that — the BLS didn't publish year-over-year CPI figures at all. Because of the government shutdown last year, they never collected the baseline data. So we have no annual comparison. We're literally making a December rate call off three monthly prints and nothing else.
Brian Reed: Three months of 0.3% core CPI. No annual context. That's — okay, let me try to say what core CPI actually is in plain terms, because I think this is where people get lost.
Brian Reed: Core CPI strips out food and energy — the stuff that swings around based on oil prices or a bad harvest. What's left is meant to show whether inflation is actually baked into the economy. Three months at 0.3% means it's not coming down despite the hikes already delivered. That's the stickiness. It's like — your landlord raised rent, your dentist raised prices, your gym raised dues — none of that follows oil prices. That's what core is measuring.
Eliza Ward: And Goolsbee's out November 13th saying the Fed 'has definitely got work to do.' Which sounds alarming until you check — he doesn't vote until 2027. He's not on the FOMC this cycle. So that's rhetorical weight, not a policy signal.
Brian Reed: So what we actually have is: one monthly CPI beat, a PPI miss, no year-over-year baseline, a non-voting Fed president sounding hawkish, and CME FedWatch pricing barely 10% odds of the 50bp move Waller flagged. That's not a unified hot picture — that's a messy one.
Eliza Ward: Messy — but here's what I think is getting called wrong out there right now. The take circulating is that Fed hawkishness is working because it's managing expectations. And I'd actually flip that.
Eliza Ward: If hawkishness were credible, traders would price 50bp higher than 10%. Waller met his own stated condition and the market shrugged. That's not managed expectations — that's the market reading that internal FOMC consensus is already well below what Waller said publicly.
Brian Reed: And that's exactly where Jim Bianco comes in, actually — he framed 25bp as the new dovish baseline. Not a moderate move, not a compromise. The floor. Which means the market has already priced the Fed as blinking, before December 8th even happens.
Eliza Ward: Right — and then Warren Pies at 3Fourteen Research takes that a step further. He's not saying inflation is the risk. He's saying the Fed itself is the risk going out in the intermediate term. Meaning — a policy misjudgment from here lands in a credit environment where the 10-year is already above 5.11% and the 2-year is at 4.87%.
Brian Reed: Hold on — the Fed is the risk, not the inflation?
Eliza Ward: That's the Pies framing, yeah. And — wait, think about why that matters concretely. Someone who took out a variable-rate business loan last spring, they're not waiting on the December 8th decision. The bond market already moved. The refinancing math already changed. Whether the Fed does 25 or 50, the damage to their rate environment is — I mean, it's already in the yield curve.
Brian Reed: So the rhetoric didn't deter anything — it just gave the market a signal about where the ceiling is, and the ceiling is 25bp.
Eliza Ward: And what happens after December 8th — whether a 25bp move reads as 'contained' or immediately gets falsified if core CPI is still at 0.3% into Q1 — that's the part we need to get to.
Brian Reed: And that's the bet, isn't it — December 8th and 9th, 25bp lands, and the Fed is functionally saying three straight months of 0.3% core CPI is manageable. Not embedded. Manageable. That's a specific claim about the future.
Eliza Ward: It's a claim they're making without year-over-year data to back it up. The BLS gap isn't a footnote — it's the missing denominator on the whole argument.
Brian Reed: So what does falsified actually look like? Like, concretely — say a January 2027 CPI print comes in at 0.3% again. What's the Fed's position then?
Eliza Ward: They have to explain why they didn't move harder when Waller himself gave them permission — in public, in London — with the data matching his stated threshold. That's not a comfortable press conference.
Brian Reed: And the bond market doesn't wait for that press conference. The 10-year is already above 5.11%. If the Fed looks like it misjudged — I mean, the credit stress is already priced in partially, but a misjudgment at that level, in that environment—
Eliza Ward: It compounds. Fast.
Brian Reed: Think about a small manufacturer trying to roll over a line of credit in February 2027. They locked nothing in December because Kalshi said 25bp was near-certain and they figured — okay, contained. Then January CPI prints 0.3%, the 89% probability reshuffles overnight, and suddenly their refinancing quote jumped before the FOMC even meets again.
Eliza Ward: Right — and the Kalshi number is real-money pricing on the current information set. It moves the moment new data arrive. 89% today is not 89% if Q1 prints come in hot.
Brian Reed: So the thing to actually watch isn't December 8th and 9th itself — it's the January and February 2027 core CPI readings. That's where the Fed finds out if it used up its permission to go bigger at exactly the wrong moment.
Eliza Ward: And that's — I mean, that's the question. Waller named the condition. November 10th, London, in public. Core at 0.3% puts 50bp on the table. Data delivered exactly that. And December 8th is still pricing 25bp at 89% on Kalshi. So either the market is correctly reading that FOMC consensus has already moved past what Waller said out loud — or it has badly underpriced a real risk. Those are genuinely different worlds.
Brian Reed: And we can't know which world we're in until — well, actually, can we know before December 8th at all? Like, is there a data release between now and the meeting that would shift those odds?
Eliza Ward: Not a CPI print — the next one lands after the meeting. So the Fed walks in without that. The open question is just sitting there.
Brian Reed: Which is — yeah, that's the uncomfortable part. If Waller's public threshold was real, December is a misjudgment. If the market is right and internal consensus already overrode him, then his London speech was — I don't know, rhetorical positioning that never had majority backing. Either way, someone is wrong about what the Fed actually is right now.
Eliza Ward: And we genuinely don't know which. That's not a hedge — that's just where the evidence stops.