Eliza Ward: Hi. Brief check-in on the mood first. Anyone else's portfolio feeling a bit sunburned?
Brian Reed: Ha. Hi. Honestly, a little. That week was ugly for anyone with money in stocks.
Eliza Ward: Ugly's right. The S&P 500 lost 8.5% and the Nasdaq about 10% in the week ending November 21. Worst since April 2025.
Brian Reed: Mm. And there was a Wall Street call in the middle of it, wasn't there? Something about the Fed?
Eliza Ward: November 19. J.P. Morgan Global Research, Michael Feroli's note. It now expects three more quarter-point hikes from the Federal Reserve, December, January, March. Up to 4.50 to 4.75%.
Brian Reed: Three more. And before, it was 'one and done'?
Eliza Ward: Yep. Dropped. But it's a forecast from one bank, not a Fed decision. Wait, I should say that more plainly. The Fed hasn't moved yet.
Brian Reed: The part I don't get, they're hiking, but not to slow the job market? Isn't slowing things down the whole point of a hike?
Eliza Ward: Think of a parent who says, one more warning and that's it. Then the kid does it again. If the parent stops now, the kid learns the warning was empty. So you follow through, even if you'd rather not.
Brian Reed: So the follow-through is the point, not the punishment. And the kid here is inflation, still stuck above the 2% target even after the earlier hikes?
Eliza Ward: That's the stated driver, yes. And 'one and done' just means one hike, then a pause. As recently as early October, J.P. Morgan had December as the last one.
Brian Reed: Early October. So about six weeks, and one hike became three.
Eliza Ward: Roughly, yeah. And here's the exact line from Feroli's note: "These hikes aren't to deliver a bad labor market, but to preserve credibility when they have no compelling narrative for a pause."
Brian Reed: Right, but a hike lands on a borrower the same way whatever the intent. If you've got a variable-rate credit line, the payment goes up either way. Nobody's checking the Fed's motives on the statement, so...
Eliza Ward: Fair. But this one's testable. If it's really credibility, stock losses shouldn't move the call. Wait, no, the note landed mid-rout, so it's not tested yet. It only counts if three holds through more red weeks.
Brian Reed: Which makes me ask, is this a genuinely new view? Or is J.P. Morgan just catching up to the Fed minutes, where most officials expected more hikes if the data warrants?
Eliza Ward: Hold on, that's the take going around, right? J.P. Morgan makes a dramatic, lonely call. I don't think it holds up. Bank of America and Deutsche Bank are reportedly on the same three-hike path.
Brian Reed: Reportedly. Is that confirmed?
Eliza Ward: No. Wait, let me say it properly. Reported means I haven't seen the actual notes. So plausible, not settled consensus. And U.S. Bank, that one's a projection: two more hikes by early 2027.
Brian Reed: Two, not three. So it isn't identical.
Eliza Ward: Same direction, different distance. And markets had a December move priced as near-certain when the J.P. Morgan note landed. So the first hike was never the bold part.
Brian Reed: Hang on, though. The minutes say most officials expect more hikes if inflation data warrants. That "if" is, I mean, it's carrying the whole sentence. Nobody at the Fed has promised three, have they? Even if the banks line up.
Eliza Ward: Right, the "if" stays. And one critic, Vance Ginn, the former Trump OMB chief economist, calls this path "the bill for easy money and deficits." That's his framing, not a finding. So the news is less "J.P. Morgan breaks from the pack," more "J.P. Morgan stops lagging." With the caveat that the pack is partly reported.
Brian Reed: Then does December still matter, with stocks sliding?
Eliza Ward: It might matter more. Is the selloff the tightening the Fed wants, or a separate stress that could force a pause? That's next, with a Tuesday-morning scenario. I don't know the answer yet.
Brian Reed: If December matters more with stocks sliding, the question is: does a 10% Nasdaq drop in a week count as tightening? Is the Fed getting some of its work done for free?
Eliza Ward: Hold on, gold's the tell. It hit a 14-month low that same week, on hawkish Fed signals and liquidations. In a real scare, gold usually catches a bid. Instead it got sold too. That reads like broad deleveraging, people selling whatever they can to raise cash. That's my inference, not a sourced conclusion.
Brian Reed: Selling what you can, not what you want. Does the Fed read it as a reason to pause, though?
Eliza Ward: The sources don't say. Nothing from the Fed on the selloff. Feroli's framing implies credibility outweighs market stress, but that's J.P. Morgan's read, not a Fed commitment. March 2023 is the precedent. Goldman Sachs and Barclays briefly dropped hike forecasts amid the banking stress. Old context, not evidence about now. Wait, and nothing like banking stress shows up in what we have. Just stocks and gold falling.
Brian Reed: So what are the warning lights, if not that?
Eliza Ward: Warnings, not events. Deutsche Bank has published charts tying hiking cycles to past financial crises. And Fed dissenters have warned about rising unemployment and falling asset prices. Real arguments, but none of it says a pause is coming.
Brian Reed: Let me put a face on it. Illustrative, not from the research. An HVAC owner, floating-rate credit line, a quote to finance two service vans. Her retirement account is down nearly 10% in a week. The hikes hit that credit line whatever the Fed intends, and she's not asking if the Fed's credibility is intact. She's asking, do I hire, do I buy the vans, do I lock in now or, I don't know, wait?
Eliza Ward: Right, and waiting is a bet on a pause nobody's promised. A December move was already priced as near-certain, so locking now mostly prices that in. January and March are the open part. That's me reasoning, not advice.
Brian Reed: Then what do we actually watch?
Eliza Ward: The December FOMC decision first. Then the next inflation and jobs prints. But here's the one that bugs me. J.P. Morgan Asset Management's 2027 Outlook says an extended Fed pause in 2027 is "increasingly likely" if the macro backdrop holds. And Feroli's Global Research has hikes in January and March 2027. Same bank, same year.
Brian Reed: Wait, so which one is it? Is that just a date gap, one note written before the other? Or do they really disagree? I honestly don't know, and I don't think the research settles it.
Eliza Ward: No, it doesn't. Publication timing, different horizon, a real split. Three readings, zero evidence picking one. The "if the macro backdrop holds" clause is doing real work, too.
Brian Reed: Hang on, and the stock drop. People hear 8.5% in a week and think recession. Is that where we are?
Eliza Ward: Not confirmed. Nothing in the sources says a recession has begun. A rout is a market signal, not contraction data. And the odds floating around, JPMorgan's 35% global, U.S. Bank's 25% for the U.S., are undated and cover different places. Don't average them.
Brian Reed: Right. So what I'm left with is, the credibility story either holds up or it doesn't. Do the next inflation and jobs numbers show a Fed protecting its word with limited damage? Or do they force J.P. Morgan to rethink January and March? I can't call it.
Eliza Ward: Me neither. December's priced in. January and March are the open part.
Brian Reed: Then I'll go check my statement before the next print.