Lila Soto: Iris, I have to tell you something that's been genuinely bothering me — like, in a good way, the kind that itches.
Lila Soto: In the 1850s, in Boston, there was this moment where art and entertainment just... lived in the same room. Same venues, mixed audiences, no one policing what counted as serious. And then — fast, like within a generation — a gate closed. High culture got sorted from popular culture. Someone built a wall and then acted like the wall had always been there.
Iris Holm: Institutional crystallization. It didn't drift — it snapped.
Lila Soto: And what's underneath that is — the objects themselves didn't earn their status. Opera was commercial entertainment. Shakespeare was... I mean, groundlings threw things. The elevation came after.
Iris Holm: So the question is: what does the elevating? Not quality. Not time. What's the actual mechanism?
Lila Soto: Universities. Museums. Archives. The institutions that confer legitimacy — and the wild proof of that is Fredric Wertham leading a moral panic that got comic books burned in churchyards in the 1950s. Same comics that now have university courses dedicated to them.
Iris Holm: Wait — church burnings specifically?
Lila Soto: School and church burnings, yeah. And New York State tried repeatedly to legislate the sale of comics to minors out of existence. That's not fringe — that's organized institutional delegitimization.
Iris Holm: And now they're archived. The boundary moved — not the work.
Lila Soto: And that's what gets me — because the clean version of this story is 'institutions decide what's good.' But Bourdieu's 1979 book, Distinction, says something weirder. It's not that institutions decide what's good. It's that your taste was never your own opinion in the first place.
Iris Holm: Say that plainly.
Lila Soto: Okay — it's like, imagine your family taught you a secret handshake starting at age four. You don't remember learning it. It just feels like how you shake hands. And then you walk into a room and other people read that handshake and immediately know what class you belong to. That's taste. That's what Bourdieu is saying.
Iris Holm: He called it cultural capital. The familiarity with legitimated culture that you absorb through upbringing, through education — it functions like money. You can convert it into social advantage.
Lila Soto: And the part that makes it stick is the habitus — that's his word for why the handshake feels natural. The dispositions are embodied. Class-specific preferences don't feel acquired. They feel like just... you.
Iris Holm: Which is why it reproduces. You don't defend it. You don't even see it.
Lila Soto: And this is a direct fight with Kant, right? Kant said aesthetic judgments are universal — beauty is ahistorical, it speaks to everyone across time. Bourdieu's whole project is essentially — no, every single one of those judgments is socially situated.
Iris Holm: Not just situated. Mapped. His actual line is — 'a socially recognized hierarchy of the arts corresponds to a social hierarchy of the consumers.' The art ladder and the class ladder are the same ladder.
Lila Soto: Oh wow — that's a stark way to put it.
Iris Holm: It is. And it has teeth because of what it predicts. Take the art school scenario — a teenager applies with a portfolio built from anime, TikTok aesthetics, game-design modding. Same technical skill. Same conceptual coherence as a classically trained applicant. But the institution reads one as legitimate training and the other as consumer hobby. The habitus of the admissions officer does that sorting automatically.
Lila Soto: And the teenager probably can't see it happening. Because to them it's just — I mean, it's just their work. That's the trap.
Iris Holm: Right. And nothing has flattened that. The boundary between legitimate art and consumer hobby is still being drawn. Just with different examples.
Lila Soto: So the question underneath all of this — what's underneath Distinction — is whether the hierarchy can ever actually dissolve. Or whether it just keeps finding new material to sort.
Iris Holm: And that's the part the surface explanation hides — it's not just that institutions decide. It's that the deciding looks like discovering.
Lila Soto: Oh — yeah, that's the sleight of hand.
Iris Holm: Canon-building reads as archiving. Neutral. Preserving what was always worth preserving. But that's not what's happening — someone is selecting. Active process. Winners and losers.
Lila Soto: And the losers just... disappear. Because if the institution doesn't stamp it, it doesn't have a shelf. It doesn't get studied. I mean, what does it even mean for a work to survive if no university decides it's worth a syllabus?
Iris Holm: It exists in some other economy. Fandom, maybe. Oral transmission. But not legitimated culture.
Lila Soto: And that's exactly when Cultural and Popular Culture Studies came in — because that field, when it rose as an academic discipline, it didn't just study comics or genre fiction. It institutionally reclassified them. It gave them a shelf. Same ink on the same pages, suddenly worth a dissertation.
Iris Holm: Which is — frankly — the mechanism completely naked. The works didn't change.
Lila Soto: And the class-reproduction piece is what makes it self-sealing, I think. Because — okay, actually, I want to make sure I have this right — the families that already hold cultural capital socialize their kids into the legitimate canon through upbringing. And then the educational institutions validate exactly those things as high-status. So the loop closes on itself.
Iris Holm: It's self-confirming. The schools don't discover that Brahms matters. They ratify what the families who fund endowments already told their children matters.
Lila Soto: So what gets called universal aesthetic value — that's not found, it's manufactured. By specific people. At specific moments.
Iris Holm: Most sociologists of culture won't even try to objectively define high culture anymore. That fight's been conceded.
Lila Soto: Hm. And jazz and comics are going to show us the mechanism with the cover off — the part that strikes me is that the institutional shift sometimes had nothing to do with aesthetics at all, which we'll get to, and it's kind of alarming.
Iris Holm: Right. The question is whether any institution ever reclassified something for purely aesthetic reasons. I'm not sure the evidence supports it.
Lila Soto: And jazz is where that becomes impossible to ignore — because the shift wasn't gradual appreciation. U.S. music education curricula, late 1960s onward. Formal inclusion. After decades of music educators treating it as, I don't know, a contamination risk.
Iris Holm: Same music. Same notes.
Lila Soto: And then — mm — conservatoire status in socialist Vietnam. Jazz goes from 'light music for the masses' to legitimate high-art discipline. Through institutional inclusion alone. That's the Even-Zohar framework, actually — Itamar Even-Zohar's polysystem theory is built exactly to track how something moves from the margin to the canon. The work doesn't migrate. The institution reclassifies.
Iris Holm: But here's what that case exposes that the comics case doesn't. The jazz legitimation in the U.S. — it wasn't aesthetic re-evaluation. It was Cold War strategy.
Lila Soto: Wait — what do you mean strategy?
Iris Holm: American institutions needed jazz — a domestic Black art form — to compete with Soviet cultural soft power in the '60s. That's the reason the legitimation happened when it did. Geopolitical pressure, not a sudden awakening to Coltrane's genius. The mechanism is operating completely naked there.
Lila Soto: Oh wow — so the same music that was morally suspect, racially coded, dismissed by educators for decades... gets institutional permission because the State Department needed a propaganda asset.
Iris Holm: And Wertham's comics panic runs the same logic in reverse. School burnings, church burnings, New York State legislating against sales to minors — that's not fringe concern. That's organized institutional force delegitimizing a medium. And now Cultural and Popular Culture Studies gives it a syllabus. So the question is — what exactly changed?
Lila Soto: Nothing changed in the work. I mean — that's the whole point, right? Same ink. What changed was who had institutional interest in permitting it.
Iris Holm: Right. And that's where I keep getting stuck — because every reclassification case, jazz, comics, whatever comes next, it doesn't weaken the hierarchy. The hierarchy absorbs it. We've never actually watched the distinction collapse. We've watched it expand its perimeter.
Lila Soto: Hm. So the proof that the hierarchy is constructed... is also proof it's durable?
Iris Holm: That's the uncomfortable move. If reclassification proves the boundary is arbitrary AND that the boundary survives every challenge — what claim does that actually leave on the table? The optimistic reading — 'expose the mechanism, dissolve the hierarchy' — the evidence doesn't support it.
Lila Soto: So every jazz or comics success story is — kind of — evidence for the system's resilience. Not its failure.
Iris Holm: The hierarchy doesn't fear reclassification. It runs on it.
Lila Soto: And that's what the cultural omnivore thing is, I think. That's the contemporary version of this exact same question. High-status people who move fluently between opera and reality TV, between the literary novel and the reality show — and it looks like the hierarchy dissolving. Like, oh, the gate is finally open. But I keep wondering what's underneath that move.
Iris Holm: It's just distinction wearing different clothes.
Lila Soto: Maybe. I mean — the sociologists who came after Bourdieu identified the omnivore as this potential challenge to strict hierarchy. But the alternative reading is that fluency across registers becomes the new elite signal. 'I can enjoy both' as its own form of cultural capital. Which would mean the hierarchy didn't dissolve. It just got — mm — harder to see.
Iris Holm: The hierarchy has absorbed jazz. It absorbed comics. Genre fiction has university syllabi now. Every single challenge — absorbed. The perimeter expanded. The sorting mechanism stayed intact. So why would the omnivore be different?
Lila Soto: It probably isn't. And the part that sits uneasily with me is — Bourdieu's whole mechanism depends on institutions having the power to gatekeep in the first place. Universities. Conservatoires. Archives. What happens when those institutions are underfunded, humanities departments are being cut, and the curator has been replaced by an algorithm?
Iris Holm: That's the infrastructure question. And I don't have a clean answer. If the legitimating power fragments — if no single institution has the authority to stamp something as canonical — the hierarchy doesn't disappear. It just becomes illegible. Which might be worse for the art still outside the gate.
Lila Soto: Yeah. That's my conclusion too, actually. The genuinely orphaned work. The stuff that never gets institutional permission — not reclassified, not absorbed, just... still waiting. And if the institutions that might have granted that permission are hollowed out, or replaced by something that optimizes for engagement instead of legitimation — what new gate even exists to walk through? I don't know who grants permission next.
Iris Holm: Neither do I. And that's probably an honest place to stop.