Onpode
Cover art for The placebo effect isn't psychology — it's real physiology working through expectation

The placebo effect isn't psychology — it's real physiology working through expectation

November 13, 2026 · 8 min

Cole Brennan & Malcolm Reeves

Hey — before we get into it, I want to put something on you, cold, see what you do with it. Go ahead. Eighty patients. Told straight out — "what you are receiving is a placebo pill made of inert substance." Still got better. More than the people who got nothing. That's Ted Kaptchuk, Harvard…

Placebo effects are genuine psychobiological responses, not imaginary improvements or reporting biases. Expectations generated through verbal information, clinician–patient interactions, treatment rituals, prior experience, and cultural context can alter nervous-system activity and produce measurable physiological changes.

0:008:11
Get the next episode on Health →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on Health →

About this episode

Placebo effects are genuine psychobiological responses, not imaginary improvements or reporting biases. Expectations generated through verbal information, clinician–patient interactions, treatment rituals, prior experience, and cultural context can alter nervous-system activity and produce measurable physiological changes.

Grounded in 11 sources
A Randomized Controlled Trial in Irritable Bowel Syndrome ↗ · journals.plos.org
A New Framework for Harnessing the Placebo Effect in ... ↗ · mbl.stanford.edu
Placebo Effects: Neurological Mechanisms Inducing Physiological, Organic, and Belief Responses—A Prospective Analysis ↗ · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
A Meta-analysis of Brain Mechanisms of Placebo Analgesia: Consistent Findings and Unanswered Questions ↗ · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Mechanisms of placebo analgesia: A dual-process model informed by insights from cross-species comparisons ↗ · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Placebo effect in the management of chronic pain - PMC ↗ · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Placebos without Deception: A Randomized Controlled Trial ... ↗ · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
The subjective experience of pain: Where expectations become reality ↗ · pnas.org
Placebo-Induced Changes in fMRI in the Anticipation and Experience of Pain | Science ↗ · science.org
Harnessing the placebo effect: A practical review of mechanisms and clinical applications | Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine ↗ · ccjm.org
Scientific American Mind March_April 2013 - cf2.org ↗ · cf2.org
Read transcript

Cole Brennan: Hey — before we get into it, I want to put something on you, cold, see what you do with it.

Malcolm Reeves: Go ahead.

Cole Brennan: Eighty patients. Told straight out — "what you are receiving is a placebo pill made of inert substance." Still got better. More than the people who got nothing. That's Ted Kaptchuk, Harvard Medical School, 2010, PLOS One. What does that do to you?

Malcolm Reeves: It makes me want to know what they were told, word for word. Because the framing matters enormously — Kaptchuk's team apparently added that placebo pills have been shown in clinical studies to produce significant improvement through mind-body self-healing. That's not nothing. That's expectation, carefully delivered.

Cole Brennan: Right — but the pill is still inert. The information is real, the pill is nothing.

Malcolm Reeves: Yes. And that's the hinge the whole story turns on — the deception was never the active ingredient. The relationship, the ritual, the expectation — those were doing the work all along, and we didn't know because we never tried removing the lie.

Cole Brennan: Which means we've been asking the wrong question for a long time — it was never "is placebo real" but, like... do we actually understand it well enough to do anything with it on purpose.

Malcolm Reeves: That's the one. That's exactly the one.

Cole Brennan: And that actually gets at the mechanism — which is the part that broke my brain a little. Because it's not vague. It's not 'the mind is powerful' or whatever. Your brain literally has its own medicine cabinet. You expect relief, it unlocks the door, dispenses actual painkillers it manufactured itself — endorphins — and they hit the exact same opioid receptors as morphine.

Malcolm Reeves: Wait — the same receptor? Literally the same binding site?

Cole Brennan: Identical. That's what made Tor Wager's 2004 Science paper so — I mean, you can't dismiss it after that. He put people in an fMRI scanner, induced pain, gave them a placebo, and watched the thalamus and the insula go quiet. Pain-processing regions just... dialing down. And the prefrontal cortex firing up during anticipation, like it's sending the order: release the medicine.

Malcolm Reeves: And that's the 1990s neuroimaging shift in miniature, right there in one study. Before you can see the brain doing it, you can say 'merely psychological.' Once Wager publishes that in Science — the word 'merely' is finished. You can't unsee the scan.

Cole Brennan: Right — but that complicates even that clean version. It's not just about belief. Expectation is the ignition switch, not willpower. You don't have to try. You just have to anticipate. That's a totally different claim.

Malcolm Reeves: Now that's — yes. Because it means the descending pain system, the top-down circuitry running from the prefrontal cortex all the way down through the brainstem to the spinal cord, that system is activated by a cognitive signal. An expectation. Not a drug.

Cole Brennan: Which means the ritual around treatment — what a clinician says, how they say it — that's not soft stuff. That's literally biology. Fabrizio Benedetti's work points exactly there.

Malcolm Reeves: And that's where this stops being just neuroscience and starts being something else — what does it mean that the relationship itself is generating measurable neurochemistry? Because that's not a metaphor anymore.

Cole Brennan: And that's exactly what I keep snagging on — if the relationship is doing biological work, then the open-label trial isn't just a curiosity. It's, like... it collapses the whole assumption that you need to deceive someone for any of that to fire.

Malcolm Reeves: Picture the actual scene. Friday afternoon, gastroenterology clinic. A woman is handed a pill bottle — labelled, literally, 'Placebo Pills — inert substance.' Her doctor says studies show these trigger real mind-body healing. And three weeks later her gut symptoms are measurably better than the control group who got nothing at all.

Cole Brennan: Should that work? Like — intuitively, shouldn't knowing destroy it?

Malcolm Reeves: That's the question Frank Miller at the NIH Department of Bioethics was sitting with. He called Kaptchuk's trial a significant step toward legitimising placebo use without ethical compromise — meaning you don't have to lie anymore. But what he was really identifying is that the ritual survived the transparency. The pill, the clinic, the clinician saying 'this works' — that package is carrying the signal even when the conscious mind knows the contents are inert.

Cole Brennan: Wait — so is it the expectation doing it, or is it the ritual running almost underneath expectation? Because those feel like different claims.

Malcolm Reeves: And that's exactly where the trial can't answer it yet. It's small — eighty patients, single condition, not replicated widely outside IBS. We genuinely don't know if conscious expectation is the driver, or if the ceremony of treatment — the white coat, the prescription, the act of swallowing something — is doing biological work almost independently.

Cole Brennan: So the lie wasn't protecting the mechanism. It was just... obscuring which part of the mechanism was actually active.

Malcolm Reeves: That's the unresolved split. And — there's a route into this that runs entirely below conscious belief, which we'll need to get to, because it goes somewhere darker than you'd expect.

Cole Brennan: I mean, darker how? Give me something.

Malcolm Reeves: Classical conditioning. That's the route that runs underneath belief entirely. You pair a pill, a syringe, a clinical setting, with a real therapeutic outcome enough times — and the neutral stimulus starts producing the response on its own. Automatically. No expectation required. We've shown this across species, which means it's not a cognitive trick. It's wired.

Cole Brennan: Wait — so a person who doesn't even believe it's going to work could still respond, just because... the ritual itself has been conditioned into them?

Malcolm Reeves: That's the claim. And it means expectation and conditioning are converging on the same downstream circuitry — the anterior cingulate cortex, the insula, nucleus accumbens — through completely different entry points. Benedetti's work is explicit on this. Two routes, one biological outcome.

Cole Brennan: Huh. So the conditioned stimulus — like, literally the act of swallowing a pill — is firing those circuits before the conscious mind even weighs in. That's actually — wait, that's not just interesting, that's kind of alarming.

Malcolm Reeves: Alarming is exactly right. Because it runs in reverse. That's the dark mirror — nocebo. Negative expectations through the identical pathways. And we're not talking about subjective discomfort. Measurable inflammatory cytokine changes. Immune suppression. The Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine documents clinicians framing side effects and patients generating the adverse effect before the drug could have caused it.

Cole Brennan: Immune markers. Not just — 'I feel worse.' Actual cytokines moving the wrong direction.

Malcolm Reeves: Actual cytokines. Which means a clinician saying 'this medication sometimes causes nausea and fatigue' is — I mean, that's not bedside manner anymore. That sentence is a biological intervention. It can condition the immune response toward harm.

Cole Brennan: So the framing of a prognosis, the specific words around side effects — that's not soft communication. Tor Wager's scanner would show something happening in those same regions in response to that sentence.

Malcolm Reeves: And that's where this whole arc lands. Meaning travels through real biology in both directions. It can reduce inflammation or raise it. Benedetti's framing — psychobiological, not psychological — that word choice is doing real work. Because if the brain is the organ generating the effect, in both directions, then every clinical interaction is already pharmacology. We've just been pretending it isn't.

Cole Brennan: And that's the part I keep — I mean, I can't quite land on it. If the clinical interaction is already pharmacology, what does that mean for how we train doctors? Not, like, as a philosophical question. Practically. Because the Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine is apparently working through exactly this — translating the mechanism into actual protocols. Which means somebody has to teach that. And right now nobody is.

Malcolm Reeves: And that's where the gap sits. We have Kaptchuk's open-label proof. We have Wager's scanner showing the biology. The question for the next decade isn't whether the effect is real — it's whether you can design a protocol, a training system, an ethical framework that harnesses it reliably. And no clinic has that yet. That work is still live and genuinely unfinished.

Cole Brennan: Which is — yeah. That's an uncomfortable place to stop. The neurobiology is there. The proof of concept is there. And the gap between those two things and a Monday morning residency training program is still enormous.

Malcolm Reeves: It is. And I think that's the honest place this conversation ends — not with a solution, but with the weight of that distance. We know more than we're using.

Cole Brennan: Good conversation. I mean that — genuinely a lot to sit with.