Zara Reyes: Hi. Quick question before anything else: when your defense of a slavery musical is an anecdote — does it help or hurt that you name the anecdote's subject as a character in the actual show?
Cole Bryant: Wait, what — that's real?
Zara Reyes: Todrick Hall. Midnight. The show is at the Daryl Roth Theatre and there is a lead character named Ethel — which is also the name of his grandmother, the one he puts in the Instagram video explaining that she picked cotton for twenty-five cents a week.
Cole Bryant: Dude. Dude okay so — wait, that means the defense and the art are kind of the same document? Like he's not separating them at all.
Zara Reyes: He explicitly says in the video that his grandmother was not an enslaved woman. So he knows the distinction. He's just — not applying it to the content question, which is what Kristin Hopkins is actually asking. Hopkins attended a preview, called it 'three hours of Black trauma,' and now the show is extended through January 2027.
Cole Bryant: Extended. So someone is saying the controversy is working for the show.
Zara Reyes: Hall is saying that. He's the one citing new interest among Black and brown teenagers as the reason. Which — no but, who's verifying that number?
Cole Bryant: Right — and is 'debate-generated interest' the same as 'people who want to see the show'? Those feel different.
Zara Reyes: But okay, debate-generated interest is actually the wrong thread — because Kristin Hopkins didn't debate the show. She attended a preview and named specific scenes.
Cole Bryant: Right — and that's the part that keeps getting buried. She's not doing a vibe review. She said costumes suspended from ropes, an early death scene, racial caricature. She sat in the Daryl Roth Theatre and pulled receipts.
Zara Reyes: And Hall's response to all of that was... the grandmother story.
Cole Bryant: Which — dude, that's not an answer to costumes on ropes. Those are two completely different conversations. It's like, imagine someone made a full romantic spectacle set during the Holocaust, and when critics said 'the staging is monstrous' their defense was 'my grandparents fled Europe.' That's real, that matters, but it doesn't tell me why the design choices are defensible.
Zara Reyes: No but — and the Act 2 inversion makes it worse, not better.
Cole Bryant: Explain that because — wait, actually I want to say it first. Hall's framing is that flipping the racial hierarchy, Black characters as slave owners, white characters enslaved, is the subversive move. The table-turn. But critics are reading it as — if you can just reverse it in Act 2, you're saying it was never that irreversible? Like, the horror of slavery is that it wasn't a scenario. It wasn't a device.
Zara Reyes: That's the click. That's the actual objection in one sentence.
Cole Bryant: And then there's the civilizing stuff — enslaved characters being taught to swim, read, write by white characters. That's not just a scene, that's a whole stereotype dressed up as plot. Critics clocked it immediately.
Zara Reyes: So the genre — romantic spectacle — is doing active damage to the subject matter. Hall keeps answering 'do I have the right to tell this story' and nobody is asking that question.
Cole Bryant: But wait — that last part is actually where Hall has something real. Like, the Page Six quote. He said he's 'not OK with someone going on social media and declaring on behalf of everyone who exists on the planet that's Black, that a musical is not for them.' That's — dude, that lands. Nobody gets to do that.
Zara Reyes: No, that's right. That part is correct.
Cole Bryant: And The Black Observer actually flagged this — Hall being the writer, director, and star is exactly the kind of narrative control Black artists have been locked out of forever. That's not nothing. That's the whole conversation about who gets to greenlight what.
Zara Reyes: He gets the partial win there. And naming the lead character Ethel — after his actual grandmother — that's not random spectacle. That's personal mythology built into the structure of the show. I'll give him that.
Cole Bryant: And the death threats. Real ones. That's — I mean, that context matters when we're talking about how this whole thing is landing on him personally.
Zara Reyes: It does. But — and this is the move Hopkins actually made — she never said he couldn't create the show. She sat in the Daryl Roth Theatre and argued the content choices don't hold up. Those are different claims. Hall keeps defending his right, Hopkins was critiquing his execution.
Cole Bryant: Oh. Yeah that's — wait, that's the whole thing isn't it. He's answering a question she didn't ask.
Zara Reyes: Picture a 16-year-old Black girl buying a ticket in November 2026 because TikTok drama sent her there. She's not arriving open. She's arriving primed. And the question is — is that the cultural purpose Hall described, or is controversy just doing marketing work now? The extension through January 2027 is the most ambiguous data point in this whole story, and we're going to have to sit with that.
Cole Bryant: Because engagement and edification are not the same ticket.
Zara Reyes: And that's the actual verdict, right — the extension through January 2027 tells you demand is real. It does not tell you *why* people are showing up. Hall says Black and brown teenagers, Complex reported the extension, The Root had the backlash in October — but none of that coverage tells us if those teenagers are supporters or curiosity-seekers who saw TikTok drama and bought a ticket.
Cole Bryant: And Hall's framing for it — 'grateful that it has sparked any conversation' — dude, that's doing so much work. 'Any conversation' is a big tent. Hate-watching is a conversation.
Zara Reyes: Controversy is not edification. Those are not the same ticket.
Cole Bryant: Right — but wait, the grandmother thing. He said it himself — she picked cotton for twenty-five cents a week but she was not an enslaved woman. He knows the distinction. So the anecdote isn't defending the show's content, it's defending his... I don't know, his emotional right to have made it? Like, those are two different arguments and he's only actually winning one of them.
Zara Reyes: He's defending his feelings about the show. Not the scenes Hopkins named.
Cole Bryant: Exactly — and that's the tell. If you have a real content defense, you answer the content question. Costumes on ropes, the death scene, the civilizing scenes. He hasn't done that anywhere — not Page Six, not Instagram. So the extension running through January 3rd, 2027 is real, the box office has a pulse, and the show is still standing. But that's ambiguity with a box office, not vindication.
Zara Reyes: Demand proved. Cultural value — genuinely unresolved.
Cole Bryant: That's the calibrated version. Hall's not wrong that no one person speaks for all Black audiences — that holds. But 'grateful for any conversation' as a defense of three hours of Black trauma is not a close. That's a pivot.
Zara Reyes: Fine. Lowkey I'll half-concede the whole thing — Hall doesn't have *no* defense. He has the wrong defense for the wrong question. That's different from having nothing.
Cole Bryant: Wait — the wrong defense for the wrong question. That's actually the most generous read possible and it still ends with 'he lost.'
Zara Reyes: He told Page Six he expected controversy but not 'the conversation that it has sparked.' Which — I mean, that's almost charming? Like he went in knowing it'd be a fight and still got blindsided by the actual fight.
Cole Bryant: Dude and the show runs through January 3rd, 2027. So he's going to be in that building, performing it, for months past the moment he admitted he didn't see this coming. That's — I don't know, bro, that's a specific kind of commitment to ambiguity.
Zara Reyes: Sparking conversation is the lowest bar in art. Midnight just cleared it by being on fire.