Onpode
Cover art for When did personal choices by historical figures alter the trajectory of events

When did personal choices by historical figures alter the trajectory of events

November 12, 2026 · 9 min

Juniper Vale & Mark Delaney

Juniper, hey — did you know that in October 1962, the Soviet Union and the U.S. came within what historians describe as hours of nuclear war, and the whole thing turned on one guy deciding not to push back? Kennedy, Cuban Missile Crisis — yeah. And that's actually the case that breaks open today's whole…

The question of whether history pivots on individual decisions or is shaped by impersonal structural forces represents one of historiography's enduring debates. The concept of "historical contingency" holds that specific moments could have unfolded differently depending on a leader's personality, judgment, or moral choices — meaning outcomes were not predetermined.

0:009:12
Get the next episode on History →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on History →

About this episode

The question of whether history pivots on individual decisions or is shaped by impersonal structural forces represents one of historiography's enduring debates. The concept of "historical contingency" holds that specific moments could have unfolded differently depending on a leader's personality, judgment, or moral choices — meaning outcomes were not predetermined.

Grounded in 12 sources
The Beginning and the End: Time, Context and the Cold War ↗ · doi.org
Chance and Necessity in History: E.H. Carr and Leon Trotsky Compared ↗ · doi.org
Historical Counterfactuals, Transition Periods, and the Constraints on Imagination ↗ · doi.org
Narratives of contingency as historical evidence for philosophical arguments of contingency: pathway decisions in the early development of molecular genetics | History and Philosophy of the Life Scien ↗ · link.springer.com
The Contingency Theory of Leadership: A Focus on Fit - PON - Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School ↗ · pon.harvard.edu
Contingency Theories of Leadership ↗ · study.sagepub.com
The Indispensable, Unlikely Leadership of Abraham Lincoln ↗ · hbr.org
Isaiah Berlin - Wikipedia ↗ · en.wikipedia.org
5 Historical Moments That Nearly Changed Everything: How Close Calls Shaped Our World ↗ · epochsandechoes.com
HISTORICAL CONTINGENCY AND THE LIMITS OF ... ↗ · gould.usc.edu
The Promise and the Perils of ↗ · h-net.org
Qualifying counterfactuals: Students' use of counterfactuals for evaluating historical explanations ↗ · journals.uclpress.co.uk
Read transcript

Mark Delaney: Juniper, hey — did you know that in October 1962, the Soviet Union and the U.S. came within what historians describe as hours of nuclear war, and the whole thing turned on one guy deciding not to push back?

Juniper Vale: Kennedy, Cuban Missile Crisis — yeah. And that's actually the case that breaks open today's whole question.

Mark Delaney: Which is — uh, what, exactly? Whether he was the reason it didn't go nuclear, or whether something else would've stopped it anyway?

Juniper Vale: Bigger than that. The question is whether individual decisions ever actually change history — or whether we just tell ourselves they do. And that question matters because a philosopher named Isaiah Berlin argued that if you believe history is a determined causal chain, moral responsibility becomes literally incoherent. His word for the doctrine he was attacking: 'historical inevitability.'

Mark Delaney: Wait — so this isn't just 'did Kennedy matter,' it's 'can we even blame or credit anyone for anything.'

Juniper Vale: Right — and there's a real disagreement here, not just philosophical hand-wraving. E.H. Carr, Leon Trotsky — they put structural forces first. Economics, class conflict, ideology. Leaders are vessels for currents that were already moving. Berlin thinks that view is dangerous because it dissolves accountability entirely.

Mark Delaney: It's kinda like saying... the river was going to flood no matter who built the levee.

Juniper Vale: That's a good way to put it — and the levee-builder is the part we keep arguing about.

Mark Delaney: And the levee-builder question — that's exactly where Churchill in 1940 wrecks my brain. Because uh, there were people inside his own War Cabinet who were genuinely asking whether Italy could mediate some kind of deal with Germany. Real officials, not fringe guys. Churchill said no. Flat no.

Juniper Vale: And then June 4th he stands up in the House of Commons and makes it public. 'We shall fight on the beaches' — that's not just rhetoric, that's closing the door on negotiation in front of everyone.

Mark Delaney: So my question is — could another prime minister have said yes to that Italian mediation? Like, was Churchill the fork, or was Britain just... going that direction anyway?

Juniper Vale: That's the exact right challenge to make. And I don't think there's a clean answer — I mean, a lot of British officials did oppose negotiating with Germany. So you could argue Churchill was just embodying a consensus that already existed. That's the structural forces case.

Mark Delaney: Right — but the part that doesn't fit is, the consensus wasn't settled. The fact that there were people actively exploring the Italy channel means the door was open. Churchill specifically slammed it.

Juniper Vale: Which is what makes it a fork moment — not just a moment where one guy mattered, but a moment where structure left room and his specific judgment filled it. Kennedy's the same mechanism. Two Soviet proposals on the table in October '62. He rejected the harder public one, accepted the initial terms, Soviets agreed October 28th. Nuclear war doesn't happen. And then — wait, this is the part people forget — a direct Washington-Moscow communications link gets built after. Arms control follows.

Mark Delaney: Hold on — there were two proposals?

Juniper Vale: Two. And the harder public one would've been nearly impossible to accept politically. Kennedy essentially picked which Soviet proposal to respond to. That's the choice. And then Lincoln — his move toward emancipation, that's the third case — that wasn't structurally mandated. That was individual moral judgment selecting one path over others the war hadn't forced yet.

Mark Delaney: So all three cases — Churchill, Kennedy, Lincoln — the structure built the stage, but somebody had to actually walk out and say their line. And a different person says a different line.

Juniper Vale: But here's where I want to push back on our own argument — because there's a methodological problem sitting right underneath all three of those cases. Niall Ferguson edited this whole collection, 'Virtual History,' specifically to rehabilitate the 'what if?' question as serious scholarship. And his claim is that counterfactual reasoning is actually the only principled way to test whether a fork moment was real. Without it, you can't tell a decision that changed history from one that just happened to accompany an outcome structural forces already locked in.

Mark Delaney: Wait — so counterfactuals aren't just interesting thought experiments, they're like... the actual test?

Juniper Vale: That's Ferguson's argument. And it's genuinely compelling until you hit the wall — you can't run the experiment. It's unfalsifiable. We'll never know if Kennedy accepting the harder Soviet proposal leads to nuclear war, because he didn't accept it.

Mark Delaney: So we're using a method to find contingency that is itself... uh, it can't be checked. That's a real problem.

Juniper Vale: And the critics — this is what keeps me up — they say fork moments might be retrospectively constructed. We work backward from the outcome and retrofit the drama. The contingency feels real because we know who won.

Mark Delaney: Okay, that's — yeah, that's kind of devastating. But like, what do you do instead? Just say we can't know anything?

Juniper Vale: Think of it like this. It's October 1962 — not Kennedy's office, not the ExComm table. A State Department analyst is at their desk, surveillance photos in front of them, and they notice an inconsistency — something that shifts Kennedy's decision timeline by six hours. Does that analyst's competence count as individual contingency? Or were they just channeling forces that made someone notice that photo eventually? Because if it's the second one, Hegel and Marx are right and we're done.

Mark Delaney: And the Civil War version of this — I mean, some scholars say the secession crisis wasn't structurally inevitable, it was specific leaders being bad at compromising. Which is — wait, that's not a force, that's just incompetence.

Juniper Vale: Exactly — and that's what counterfactual analysis of the secession crisis actually concludes. Not tragedy, not destiny, just particular people unwilling to make necessary concessions. And honestly, that connects to something we haven't gotten to yet — if contingency is real, then moral accountability isn't symbolic, and that changes something pretty concrete about how we actually pick and judge leaders.

Mark Delaney: And that's — yeah, that's the part that actually lands for me. Because if the secession crisis was just bad diplomacy, not destiny, then we can't let leaders off the hook by calling it structural. Berlin's not being abstract. He's saying you *have* to judge them. That's a logical requirement, not a preference.

Juniper Vale: And it cuts both ways. You have to praise them too. Which is what Berlin actually argued — historians aren't just chroniclers, they're moral evaluators. That's not optional if you accept agency.

Mark Delaney: Okay but — wait, here's where I want to bring in something that kind of reframes this. Fred Fiedler, 1960s psychologist, he builds out this contingency theory of leadership effectiveness, and his whole finding is that the same leader can be decisive in one situation and totally irrelevant in another. Like, it's not that the person is great — it's that the moment fit them.

Juniper Vale: Which actually doesn't let the structuralists win — it makes the matching question the thing that matters. Who do you put *in* that specific situation.

Mark Delaney: Right — so it's not 'great man theory' exactly, it's more like... uh, right context, right person, real consequence. And that means selection matters. Who you pick for which role, when.

Juniper Vale: Gorbachev, 1989 — not firing on protesters. If that decision was contingent, genuinely not structurally locked in, then every analyst who calls a geopolitical outcome inevitable right now is potentially blind to the exact moment that matters most.

Mark Delaney: That's — okay, that's a little alarming actually.

Juniper Vale: It should be. Structural analysis might be systematically worst at the moments that are most consequential. Because those are exactly the fork points where one person's judgment overrides the current.

Mark Delaney: And that's — uh, that's the thing that sits with me. We can't actually know if we're at a fork until after. Like, Kennedy in October '62 didn't know he was at the hinge. He just made a call.

Juniper Vale: Which is exactly the uncomfortable place Berlin leaves us. If determinism is true, nobody's ever actually responsible — not Hitler, not Churchill, not Lincoln moving toward emancipation. But if contingency is true, nobody gets to say the structure made them do it. And we still don't have a clean test for which one is operating while it's happening.

Mark Delaney: So the honest answer is just — stay sharp enough to notice when you might be in one of those moments. Even if you can't prove it.

Juniper Vale: That's probably the only real takeaway. Not a resolution — just that the question demands something from you. Thanks for thinking through it with me.