Onpode
Cover art for Why empires fail in similar ways despite different geographies and centuries

Why empires fail in similar ways despite different geographies and centuries

November 15, 2026 · 9 min

Alex Mercer & Jordan Hale

Alex, hey — did you sleep okay this week, because I genuinely could not stop thinking about something and it is going to sound like a weird thing to lose sleep over. I'm guessing it involves dead empires. Okay, yes, but hear me out — Rome, right, the whole military apparatus, by the 2nd century…

Imperial collapse across vastly different historical eras shares a recognizable structural pattern rather than unique, isolated causes. The core dynamic is a "capacity gap": territorial commitments, military obligations, and administrative costs expand faster than the state's ability to tax, supply, and govern them.

0:008:44
Get the next episode on History →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on History →

About this episode

Imperial collapse across vastly different historical eras shares a recognizable structural pattern rather than unique, isolated causes. The core dynamic is a "capacity gap": territorial commitments, military obligations, and administrative costs expand faster than the state's ability to tax, supply, and govern them.

Grounded in 10 sources
The Sources of Renewed National Dynamism ↗ · rand.org
War and Peace and War: The Rise and Fall of Empires - Ayalamip ↗ · ayalamip.com.py
White Paper: Why Roman Britain Ended in Usurpers: Institutional Fragmentation, Military Autonomy, and the Collapse of Imperial Order in the Early Fifth Century | Edge Induced Cohesion ↗ · edgeinducedcohesion.blog
Historiography of the fall of the Western Roman Empire - Wikipedia ↗ · en.wikipedia.org
The Long Shadow of Rome: Linda Colley on Edward Gibbon, Decolonization, and the Ghosts and Enemies of Empire | HUN-REN ↗ · hun-ren.hu
InequalitiesWithin-Polities and in Interpolity Relations ... - IROWS ↗ · irows.ucr.edu
The Accounting of Empires. Administrative, Economic, and Strategic Analysis of Civilizations in Historical Order | Lawyers Week ↗ · lawyersweek.net
Cliodynamics | Peter Turchin ↗ · peterturchin.com
Power Has a Pattern: History Might Repeat Itself ↗ · submissions.regionaltribune.com
USA: Seven stages of imperial decline – Samannay Biswas | VOICE OF INDIA ↗ · voiceofindia.me
Read transcript

Jordan Hale: Alex, hey — did you sleep okay this week, because I genuinely could not stop thinking about something and it is going to sound like a weird thing to lose sleep over.

Alex Mercer: I'm guessing it involves dead empires.

Jordan Hale: Okay, yes, but hear me out — Rome, right, the whole military apparatus, by the 2nd century AD it was eating seventy to eighty percent of all imperial revenue. Seventy. To. Eighty. That means everything else — roads, courts, the actual bureaucracy that collects the money in the first place — that's running on maybe twenty cents of every dollar. How does that even function?

Alex Mercer: It doesn't, eventually. That's kind of the whole point.

Jordan Hale: Right — but wait, no, what actually got me was that this isn't just a Rome thing. Spain in 1580, troops on four continents, and military spending is already past fifty percent of government revenues. Fifteen centuries later, same trap. That feels like it shouldn't be a coincidence.

Alex Mercer: It probably isn't. Paul Kennedy called it imperial overstretch — military commitments expanding beyond the fiscal capacity to sustain them. And Edward Gibbon was already gesturing at this in the 18th century: the further an empire extends its frontiers, the more vulnerable it becomes. Neither of them were describing the same empire.

Jordan Hale: Which is — yeah, that's the thing that won't let me go. Is this a pattern? Like, structurally forced to repeat? Or are we just really good at finding the shape we're looking for?

Alex Mercer: That's basically the question we're sitting with today. And I don't think there's a clean answer — not yet.

Jordan Hale: So if the pattern is real — and I'm not saying it is yet — what does it actually feel like from the inside? Like, what's the mechanism that tips you over?

Alex Mercer: Think of it like a small business owner who opens a second location before the first one is profitable. The new location needs staff, rent, inventory — it's immediately pulling cash out of the original store. At some point you hit the break-even threshold: new territory costs more to garrison than it produces. That's the whole thing. That's the capacity gap.

Jordan Hale: And Rome just... kept opening new locations.

Alex Mercer: Northern Britain and the Rhineland — both net fiscal losses. Rome wasn't extracting surplus from those regions, it was paying to hold them. For prestige, mostly, or this idea that the frontier had to be somewhere visible. Strategic inertia is probably the cleaner term. And once you're locked into that, you can't just walk away without it looking like the whole project is unraveling.

Jordan Hale: Wait — so why not just leave? Like, actually pull back from northern Britain, stop bleeding cash?

Alex Mercer: Because admitting a frontier isn't worth holding is — I mean, it's basically announcing the empire has limits. Which is politically catastrophic. So instead you do the two things that feel like solutions but aren't. You debase the currency — shave the silver content of the coins — and you squeeze the core populations harder. More taxes from the people closest to Rome, who are already taxed. And that's when it starts feeding itself, because you're compressing the economic productivity of the very base that funds everything else.

Jordan Hale: And the people being squeezed aren't exactly thrilled about subsidizing a province nobody's making money from.

Alex Mercer: Exactly — domestic resentment builds precisely when you need revenue stability most. It's the fiscal feedback loop tightening. The currency debasement and extraction aren't symptoms of the collapse, they're part of what accelerates it.

Jordan Hale: But here's the part that actually messes with me — losing a province isn't just a setback you absorb. It's a ratchet. Like, picture a Roman quartermaster in fifth-century Britain, right? The tax receipts from the province next door just disappeared because that province is now contested. His legion doesn't get paid. So his general starts extracting from nearby settlements instead — and then, you know, that general starts looking around and thinking, why am I loyal to someone four hundred miles away who can't supply me?

Alex Mercer: And Roman Britain ran through exactly that — a succession of usurper emperors in the early fifth century, one after another. Each usurpation normalized the idea that authority flows upward from troops, not downward from Rome.

Jordan Hale: Wait — multiple usurpers? Like, repeatedly?

Alex Mercer: Repeatedly. Because the civil governance had basically hollowed out. The army becomes the only functional institution left — so of course the commander starts acting like a sovereign. That's not corruption, that's rational adaptation to a broken supply chain.

Jordan Hale: And once that happens — once legitimacy is coming from the troops and not the center — the center is kind of already gone, right? Even if it doesn't know it yet. Peter Turchin has a name for the inside dynamics of that, doesn't he?

Alex Mercer: Secular cycles — his cliodynamics framework. Elite overproduction is the specific mechanism: too many people competing for administrative positions that are shrinking because the revenue base is shrinking. That competition accelerates corruption, which fragments the center faster. It's not one cause, it's the loop tightening from the inside simultaneously with the frontier collapsing from the outside.

Jordan Hale: And Ibn Khaldun — I mean, he was watching something similar but framing it as asabiya, right? The frontier peoples have this group solidarity the urban elites have already lost, so when the center weakens, it's not random who fills the gap.

Alex Mercer: That's the closing move on the loop. The people with cohesion are on the edges. The people at the soft center are competing with each other. So the ratchet isn't reversible — each frontier you lose reduces the tax base and recruitment pool, which makes the next frontier harder, which loses you more revenue.

Jordan Hale: Which — okay, that's the thing that should terrify anyone paying attention, because we haven't even gotten to whether this actually predicts anything or whether we're just — you know, really eloquently retrofitting. Spain, Britain's post-WWII debt blowing past GDP — that's coming and it complicates this more than I expected.

Alex Mercer: I think that's exactly where the pattern gets genuinely uncomfortable to look at.

Jordan Hale: Spain is where it stops feeling theoretical for me, because — okay, 1580, over fifty percent of revenues gone to the military, troops on four continents, and I keep thinking about what that actually looks like on the ground. Some finance clerk in Madrid getting requisition orders from the Netherlands, from Peru, from the Philippines, all in the same week.

Alex Mercer: And the math just doesn't close. That's not mismanagement — that's the capacity gap in writing. Over fifty percent to the military by 1580 means Spain hit the threshold Rome hit, just faster, because four continents compresses the timeline.

Jordan Hale: Did they know, though? Like, did anyone in Madrid see it?

Alex Mercer: Probably, to some extent. But the incentives don't reward seeing it. Pulling back from the Netherlands means admitting the same thing Rome couldn't admit about Britain.

Jordan Hale: And Britain — wait, this is the part that actually reframed everything for me. Everyone frames decolonization as this moral reckoning, right, this choice. But the national debt after World War II exceeded GDP. That's not a choice, that's a balance sheet.

Alex Mercer: Debt exceeding GDP — that's not a metaphor for strain, that's a hard number. And it forced decolonization regardless of anyone's political intentions. Britain didn't gracefully withdraw. It ran out of runway.

Jordan Hale: Which — nobody tells that story! So same structural outcome, three different empires, but then Linda Colley would push back and say Rome's 'collapse' isn't even the right word, because Roman law and language were still running institutions for centuries after the military fragmented.

Alex Mercer: Right — but that's actually the honest tension. The fiscal mechanism repeats. The outcome doesn't. Rome transforms over centuries. Britain compresses it into a decade. So are we finding a pattern, or are we — I mean, are we finding the story we came looking for?

Jordan Hale: And that's what makes Turchin's cliodynamics either brilliant or slightly terrifying — he's trying to test it mathematically, but every example we have already fell. We're fitting the curve after the fact.

Alex Mercer: That's the real limit. Retrospective pattern versus predictive model — those are not the same thing. And until cliodynamics can tell us which state hits the capacity gap next, the question stays open: genuine structural law, or a very useful story.

Jordan Hale: And that's the thing that settled on me, you know — if Turchin is right, if cliodynamics is actually capturing something real, the value isn't predicting which state cracks next. It's just... earlier recognition of the strain. That's all.

Alex Mercer: And even that might be too optimistic. Because the political incentives that drove the overextension in the first place are the same ones that make recognition inconvenient. Spain in 1580 didn't lack the numbers. They lacked the permission to act on them.

Jordan Hale: So the pattern might be real and completely useless at the same time. That's — yeah, that's an uncomfortable place to land.

Alex Mercer: Honest, though. I'll take honest over clean. Good talk.