David Sterling: Megan, hey — I've been sitting with this one all morning and I keep arriving at the same uncomfortable place.
Megan Skiendel: Same, honestly. It's one of those things that looks boring on the surface and then you pull one thread.
David Sterling: Here's the plain version of what we're trying to figure out today: when the Federal Reserve raises rates, why does your mortgage adjust almost immediately — but your savings account just... sits there?
Megan Skiendel: And the answer isn't a glitch.
David Sterling: No. The variable-rate mortgage is literally contractually indexed — wired to EURIBOR or the federal funds rate. It reprices within days. Mechanically. No discretion. But the deposit side carries no such linkage. The bank just... doesn't have to move. And so it doesn't.
Megan Skiendel: The ECB's 2022–23 tightening cycle made this impossible to look away from. Rates rose sharply — faster than anyone predicted — and loan costs jumped almost immediately. Deposit rates? Markedly weaker pass-through than historical patterns suggested. Documented right through 2024 data. That's not a lag. That's interest rate pass-through asymmetry at scale, and it held across nearly every Euro area country they tracked.
David Sterling: The net interest margin widening that followed — banks earning more on loans immediately while paying depositors barely anything extra for months — that's not an accident. That's the mechanism. And it's been hiding in plain sight.
Megan Skiendel: But that's the clean version — and the clean version leaves out the part that makes it actually strange. Because it's not just that banks *can* sit still on deposit rates. It's that most depositors never make them move. The Becker Friedman Institute formalized this — they call them sleepy deposits. Retail depositors leave money in the same account for years even when better yields are sitting right next to them.
David Sterling: So the inertia is the product, not the side effect.
Megan Skiendel: Exactly — and here's the mechanism that I think gets missed. When rates rise, the people who *do* pay attention leave. They move to time deposits, money markets, whatever. That's rate-sensitive depositor sorting. And the ones who stay? They're the least price-sensitive pool you could possibly have. So the bank's market power over those remaining depositors actually *increases*.
David Sterling: Wait — so the people waking up and switching are, what, inadvertently making it worse for everyone who stays?
Megan Skiendel: That's the vicious circle. Think about a retiree rolling over a CD at their branch bank — autopilot, 0.5%, hasn't looked at a rate sheet in eighteen months. Meanwhile Marcus is offering 4.5%. It's not laziness exactly, it's friction they never got around to resolving. And the deposit market power research on concentrated banking systems — the Euro area data running through 2024 — shows this pattern holds across countries, though I'd hedge that heavily because things may be shifting.
David Sterling: The load-bearing assumption there is that sleepy deposits stay asleep. The 2023 regional banking crisis — that's where that assumption gets stress-tested and fails. Research found no evidence those banks proactively managed deposit-run risk beforehand. Zero.
Megan Skiendel: And the part that comes next — digital banks actually tried to crack this in 2022–23 by passing rates through faster, and what happened to their margins and lending capacity is a whole other story.
David Sterling: And they paid for that attempt. Digital banks in 2022–23 — they moved faster on deposit rates, passed more through. And the consequence was margin compression that then constrained their lending. They proved the asymmetry is contestable. They also proved the price of contesting it is you stop growing.
Megan Skiendel: Which is a strange kind of winning.
David Sterling: Right — and their market share is still negligible. So even with the margin hit, the structural funding advantage of the Canadian large banks — 70 to 80 basis points cheaper than smaller peers — that gap doesn't close. That's not competitive pressure working. That's competitive pressure being absorbed.
Megan Skiendel: And the BIS flagged something that I think ties directly here — digitalisation and social media are what let digital banks attract rate-sensitive depositors faster. Same tools that accelerate deposit gathering can accelerate deposit flight. That's the two-edged thing nobody modeled cleanly before March 2023.
David Sterling: Which is what makes the BFI framing genuinely uncomfortable. They argue sleepy deposits bolster stability — let banks fund long-term loans. That's the feature, not the bug. But the 2023 regional banking crisis research, published 2025 — no evidence of proactive balance-sheet management beforehand. None. So regulators are building stability assumptions on something that can evaporate in a weekend.
Megan Skiendel: A weekend driven by a tweet.
David Sterling: Frankly, yes. So what does that do to the model? If deposit awareness is a variable that's rising — not flat — the stability assumption isn't stable.
Megan Skiendel: And digital banks' current share is too small to shift aggregate pass-through for the whole system. So the asymmetry probably persists — I mean, the incumbents still hold most of the pool — but the floor under it is thinner than anyone was pricing in.
David Sterling: I keep arriving back at the original thing — the mortgage that reprices in days versus the savings account that just sits there. Same rate cycle. Same borrower, sometimes. And the gap isn't closing. The interest rate pass-through asymmetry is structural, it's held across every cycle the ECB and BIS have documented, and the whole thing runs on depositors not looking. That's the bet. And the digital tools that might erode it — open banking, comparison apps — they lower switching costs, sure, but whether digital banks have enough market share to actually move aggregate pass-through for the system... I mean, we genuinely don't know that. The numbers don't support it yet.
Megan Skiendel: And the uncomfortable part is nobody has a clean answer for what happens if it fails at scale. Not the Federal Reserve, not the ECB, not the regulators citing the BFI stability framing. The 2023 regional crisis was a weekend. That's the data point that doesn't fit neatly anywhere.
David Sterling: The savings account still sits there. That's where we started, and honestly that's still where we are.