Onpode
Cover art for Why some works enter the canon and others vanish — the institutional selection mechanism

Why some works enter the canon and others vanish — the institutional selection mechanism

November 20, 2026 · 12 min

Michael C. Vincent & Mark Delaney

Hey — before we get into anything, I uh, I need to tell you that I've been weirdly annoyed all morning and I think it's because of this topic. Annoyed how. Like — okay, the Sweden government released this list, the kulturkanon, a hundred things that count as Swedish culture. IKEA is on it. Paternity…

Cultural canons — the collections of "great works" taught in schools, displayed in museums, and analyzed by critics — are formed through institutional gatekeeping rather than objective assessments of quality.

0:0012:29
Get the next episode on Culture →

Follow it free — new episodes land in your feed.

Or make your own — any topic, in minutes

More Onpode episodes on Culture →

About this episode

Cultural canons — the collections of "great works" taught in schools, displayed in museums, and analyzed by critics — are formed through institutional gatekeeping rather than objective assessments of quality.

Grounded in 12 sources
Post-factual music historiography: Legends of art-religion ↗ · doi.org
Shifting Identities of Feminism to Challenge Classical Music Canon Practices: A Beginners Guide to Guerrilla Gender Musicology ↗ · doi.org
Forum—Centering Discomfort in Global Music History ↗ · doi.org
On the future of music history in professional and central-peripheral European musical circumstances ↗ · doi.org
Writing the History of "Ottoman Music" ↗ · doi.org
Troubling the Canon: Language, Geography, and the Politics of STS ... ↗ · pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
The Country That Made Its Own Canon | The New Yorker ↗ · newyorker.com
The Western Canon: The Books and School of the Ages - Bloom, Harold: 9780151957477 - AbeBooks ↗ · abebooks.com
The Western Canon: The Books and School of the Ages: Bloom, Harold: 9780151957477: Amazon.com: Books ↗ · amazon.com
“Forgotten Tales” of Women Composers at London's Royal ... ↗ · asset.library.wisc.edu
Chicken and Egg: Mechanics of Exclusion in the Literary Canon – Forms and Contexts of Literary Studies ↗ · blogs.dickinson.edu
1 Canon Creation/Destruction and Cultural Formation: Authority, Reception, Canonicity, Marginality in: Canonisation as Innovation ↗ · brill.com
Read transcript

Mark Delaney: Hey — before we get into anything, I uh, I need to tell you that I've been weirdly annoyed all morning and I think it's because of this topic.

Michael C. Vincent: Annoyed how.

Mark Delaney: Like — okay, the Sweden government released this list, the kulturkanon, a hundred things that count as Swedish culture. IKEA is on it. Paternity leave is on it. Laws are on it. And I keep thinking, someone sat in a room and just... decided. And then called it culture.

Michael C. Vincent: Now that is the thing, isn't it. We bristle at Sweden for being so open about it. But the question is whether every other canon is doing the same thing, just less honestly.

Mark Delaney: Okay yeah — yeah, that's actually the thing that's nagging me.

Michael C. Vincent: You see, I want to give you a human image that I think is the sharper edge of this. Rebecca Clarke — British composer, her string quintet performed and written about by serious musicians for decades. She was living in New York, in her eighties, and a classical radio host had to track her down. She believed she had been forgotten. She did not know she mattered.

Mark Delaney: Wait — she didn't know? While her music was actively out there being discussed?

Michael C. Vincent: While serious musicians were performing and writing about her string quintet, yes. Because the institutions — the conservatories, the curricula — had simply never included her. And the absence looked, from inside, like being forgotten.

Mark Delaney: That's erasure that felt like nothing was happening. That's — man, that's a different thing than obscurity.

Michael C. Vincent: But here is where the story turns — Clarke and Sweden's kulturkanon are actually the same question from opposite ends. One is what happens when the machinery excludes you quietly. The other is what happens when the machinery operates in public. The canon was always constructed. Someone always writes the list.

Mark Delaney: And the list gets repeated by universities, museums, critics, prize committees — until the choices look like they were never choices at all.

Michael C. Vincent: That's the central strangeness we're sitting with today.

Mark Delaney: But here's what I keep getting stuck on — like, that construction, it doesn't feel like construction from the inside. And I think that's actually the whole mechanism. I've got this image in my head of a ninth-grade English teacher, Tuesday in September, planning her year. She's got the district's approved curriculum list in front of her. She wants to add someone new, she's thinking about it. But the textbooks don't have those lessons prepped, the exam doesn't cover the new author, and she's got forty papers to grade. So Shakespeare stays.

Michael C. Vincent: And Shakespeare stays — not because he's objectively the best.

Mark Delaney: Because changing it costs time nobody has. That's it. That's the whole thing.

Michael C. Vincent: And that is the mechanism, plainly stated: a work is chosen, then accumulates scholarship around it, then its status looks self-evident — when actually the advantage was produced by the original choice. You see, that teacher's students grow up, some of them become teachers, and they teach Shakespeare because that's what a ninth-grade curriculum looks like.

Mark Delaney: Selection, consecration, repetition. And then the repetition gets mistaken for proof.

Michael C. Vincent: Now — Sweden's kulturkanon makes this exact process visible, because someone actually wrote it down. A government committee, September, one hundred works. Ingmar Bergman on the list. IKEA on the list. Paternity leave on the list. No pretense that it emerged from anywhere. Someone decided.

Mark Delaney: And we find that uncomfortable — but uh, wait, is the discomfort because they're doing something wrong, or just because they're doing it out loud?

Michael C. Vincent: That's the right question. The truth is a touch more complicated than 'Sweden is unusual.' Every syllabus committee does this. No conspiracy required. A professor proposes the texts they know. No one argues hard. It's approved. The gatekeeping is — it's inertia, really. Mundane and durable.

Mark Delaney: Mundane is actually the scariest version of it, I think. Like, malicious I could fight. Lazy I don't even know where to grab.

Michael C. Vincent: Exactly so.

Mark Delaney: And that's the part Harold Bloom never really sat with, right? Like, his whole argument in The Western Canon — 1994, big book — is that literary merit is real, that aesthetic standards exist, and that bringing politics into it ruins genuine literary study. But that argument only works if the starting conditions were neutral. And the ninth-grade teacher on Tuesday tells you they weren't.

Michael C. Vincent: Well — I'd tell it a little differently on Bloom. He isn't entirely wrong that some works are structurally harder, more resistant. But the question is whether difficulty earns you an institutional seat. And the answer, clearly, is: not automatically. The works that got the seat got the scholarship, the performances, the preservation. That's the advantage the selection produces. And then the advantage looks like proof the selection was right all along.

Mark Delaney: And that's the part that gets me — the advantage looks like proof. That's not a side effect, that's the whole engine, right? Like, once a work gets selected, it gets the scholarship, the performances, the preservation, and then fifty years later someone points at all that and goes 'see, clearly it deserved to be here.'

Michael C. Vincent: That's exactly the circularity. And Bloom walks right into it.

Mark Delaney: How so — I mean, he's making the merit argument in good faith, isn't he?

Michael C. Vincent: He is. And that's what makes The Western Canon interesting rather than just wrong. Bloom publishes it in 1994, he's genuinely arguing that literary individuality, poetic autonomy — these are real things, measurable things, not politics dressed up as taste. And he's not stupid. But his list runs heavily British, American, Western European. The criteria he uses to assess greatness were developed inside the same institutional tradition whose outputs he's evaluating.

Mark Delaney: So he's using a ruler to prove the ruler is accurate.

Michael C. Vincent: You see, that is the neatest version of it. And he attacks anyone who notices this — he calls the whole feminist, Marxist, New Historicist, Lacanian, deconstructionist crowd the 'school of resentment.' His word. Resentment. As if political awareness is just sour grapes.

Mark Delaney: Okay but — wait, here's what I actually want to push on. Whitman's in the canon. Dickinson's in the canon. Colette's in the canon. All three of them have marginalized identities, queer identities, and they got there before any explicit revisionist push. So doesn't that complicate the 'it's just power' story a little?

Michael C. Vincent: It complicates it. It doesn't dissolve it. Because their inclusion doesn't tell you the selection was merit-based — it tells you the mechanism isn't a simple mirror of social power. It's messier. Some genuinely difficult work does break through. But that's not proof the door was open. It might just be proof that occasionally someone kicks it hard enough.

Mark Delaney: Huh. Yeah — and even then, once they're in, they get the same treatment. The visibility, the scholarship. So now their inclusion feels inevitable too.

Michael C. Vincent: That is the self-reinforcing cycle made flesh. The machinery doesn't care how you got in. Once you're in, it starts producing reasons you deserved it.

Mark Delaney: So Bloom's not wrong that Whitman is hard and rewarding and structurally complex. He's just — he can't tell whether that's why Whitman's canonical or whether Whitman being canonical is why that feels so obvious to him now.

Michael C. Vincent: Now that is the question he never asks himself.

Mark Delaney: And the thing that makes me uh — honestly a little uneasy — is what this means for the Rebecca Clarkes. Because even when institutions go back to 'rediscover' someone, I'm not sure that's the right word for what's actually happening, and I think where that leads is darker than the rediscovery story lets on.

Michael C. Vincent: And that word — rediscovery — that's the tell, isn't it. It implies the work was simply waiting somewhere. Tucked in a drawer. Patient.

Mark Delaney: Right — but Clarke wasn't in a drawer. She was alive. In New York. The work was performed.

Michael C. Vincent: The language of rediscovery does something specific: it moves the agency onto the finder. Some heroic archivist stumbles across the manuscript. And that framing — it erases the institution that did the excluding.

Mark Delaney: Okay and — this is the part that I keep — wait, there's actually scholarship on this exact mechanism. Chanda VanderHart and Abigail Gower, they wrote specifically about gendered gatekeeping in classical music canon practices. And what they're documenting isn't that women composers were obscure. It's that institutions made active decisions to exclude them.

Michael C. Vincent: Active decisions that then looked, decades later, like natural absence.

Mark Delaney: And then there's this concept — Mirjana Veselinović-Hofman calls it peripheral musicologies. The idea being that non-Western music traditions get judged by standards that were set at Western centers of evaluation. So it's not that the music is peripheral. It's that the measuring stick was built somewhere else and then declared universal.

Michael C. Vincent: Imagine that. The standard travels with the institution.

Mark Delaney: I'm not sure I'm fully right on this — even when people try to fix it, the American Musicology Society started this Global Music History Study Group in 2019, Yvonne Liao and Olivia Bloechl founded it specifically to resist hegemonic pasts in music historiography. That's their actual phrase. But — and this is the part that's weird — it operates through academic societies. Scholarly publishing. The same machinery.

Michael C. Vincent: You don't get new centers. You get the same center with a broader intake.

Mark Delaney: Which is — yeah, that's the thing that unsettles me more than the original problem.

Michael C. Vincent: Now, Sweden's kulturkanon makes this concrete in a way that's almost too neat. Hilma af Klint — Swedish abstract painter — she's on the 2025 list. And the coverage treats it as recognition. But that's not what's happening. A government committee constructed her canonical status. In real time. The list didn't find her importance. It produced it.

Mark Delaney: So Sweden is just doing loudly what every institution does quietly. And af Klint is now canonical because — literally because someone wrote her name on a list in September.

Michael C. Vincent: And thirty years from now, that status will look self-evident. The scholarship will have accumulated. The mechanism completes itself.

Mark Delaney: So rediscovery isn't the right word for Clarke, it isn't the right word for af Klint — I mean, what's the right word? Because I think naming it correctly is actually where the problem either gets legible or stays hidden.

Michael C. Vincent: The right word might be — legible. Making the choice legible. Because the problem with 'rediscovery' isn't just that it's imprecise. It's that it hides the agent. No one is accountable. The institution that excluded Clarke isn't named. It just — recedes into 'the way things were.' And once you can't see who chose, you can't argue with the choice.

Mark Delaney: And that's — wait, that's actually what Sweden gets right, even if everything else about it is uncomfortable. The kulturkanon is a government document. Someone's name is on it. You can argue with it.

Michael C. Vincent: And I keep turning this over — not the list itself, not whether Hilma af Klint belongs or whether IKEA belongs. The fact that the choice is visible and therefore contestable. Because the alternative isn't no canon. The alternative is a canon that feels inevitable. And an inevitable canon is the one you absolutely cannot argue with. The durability of these things — across centuries of actual debate, revisionist pressure, the whole school of resentment Bloom was so furious about — that durability suggests expanding who's included doesn't dismantle the gatekeeping. It just moves who holds the gate.

Mark Delaney: Yeah. That's — uh, that's the uneasy place I land too, honestly. Not that we shouldn't try. Just that the trying doesn't get you out of the mechanism.

Michael C. Vincent: So the question isn't whether to have canons. It's whether the teacher on Tuesday, the acquisitions committee, the AMS study group — whether they can operate in a way that admits they're choosing. That treats the choice as temporary. That keeps the door to argument open.

Mark Delaney: Provisional. The word I keep wanting is provisional. Like — we picked these twenty authors this year, and that's what we're calling it. Not canonical. Just this year's list.

Michael C. Vincent: That's where I'd leave it. Not a verdict. Just that image — the teacher, the committee, the government in Stockholm — all making finite choices, and the only honest version of that is one where the choices could visibly be made differently. That's enough to sit with.